Thursday, October 21, 2010

Taking stock of Mr. Singh

When Prime Minister Manmohan Singh started his second term a year ago, there was considerable optimism in the air: Voters had marginalized small parties with petty, parochial agendas; the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party was in disarray; and Mr. Singh’s Congress Party had a strong political mandate. Given Mr. Singh’s profession as an economist and his role in India’s 1991 big-bang economic reforms, hopes were high that he would continue the reform agenda.

A year later, the government has produced only marginal action. The long-awaited third-generation mobile-phone spectrum auctions finally took place; disinvestment in public-sector companies is on track; and the national highways program, which languished under Congress’s first-term government, has been revived. Mr. Singh, to his credit, has laid special emphasis on fixing the country’s terrible infrastructure.

But, regrettably, little has been done in the spirit of real liberalization—that is, to roll back state from economy and increase the influence of the private sector in the economy. For instance, the government is selling minority stakes in state-run companies to dress up fiscal figures, not actually privatizing them, as its predecessor BJP-led government did. Major industries, such as banking and energy, remain largely state-run.

Nothing has been done to eliminate the residual legacies of the pre-1991, socialist past. India’s labor laws are antiquated and need to be made more flexible so that companies can react to changing market conditions. During Mr. Singh’s first term in office, he could never have contemplated reform in this area because of his alliance with the Communist Party. Yet now he’s ditched that alliance and still hasn’t touched this important area of reform.

Nor has Mr. Singh strengthened property-rights protection, either in the physical or intellectual sense. Farmers, especially in tribal areas, still have little right to transfer land they occupy and till. Companies, both domestic and foreign, struggle to protect their intellectual property. In one recent example, the Supreme Court denied Novartis a patent on a major cancer drug on the grounds that it wasn’t a major “innovation.” The company is appealing the decision, but the message to foreign investors has already been sent.

If anything, the Congress Party-led government has worked against the spirit of economic reforms. The most prominent example of this is the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, created during Congress’s first term in office. The scheme guarantees the rural poor 100 days of work at the taxpayer’s expense. Apart from bleeding the public fisc to the tune of Rs 40,000 crore, the Act is creating conditions for permanent serfdom, with the Indian state as the feudal lord and millions as dependents. Congress has also expanded the state’s remit in education and is considering passing a Right to Food Act, which would further increase deficit.

Politics remains the major impediment to reform. Mr. Singh is unelected to his own parliamentary seat and has no political base of his own. The real power in the Congress is chairwoman Sonia Gandhi, who reigns as what the BJP policy makers like to call a kind of “super-prime minister.” She takes care of the political affairs of the party and the ruling coalition, while Mr. Singh takes care of the day-to-day running of government. Her most recent intervention was in favor of a caste-based census, a backward-looking suggestion that the BJP also supports.

India can’t afford this kind of left-leaning governance. The world’s most populous democracy is still a very poor country, with hundreds of thousands of people lacking even the most basic necessities. So long as New Delhi tries to solve all problems with the state, the slower growth will be—and the more people will be confined to poverty. A weak state also can’t confront the growing internal and external security threats the country faces; in particular, Maoist violence which has killed hundreds over the past year over vast swathes of the country.

Mr. Singh isn’t an economic neophyte; he understands what needs to be done. But will he stand up to Mrs. Gandhi and push reform? If he doesn’t, the drift will only continue and deepen.


This article was published in Wall Street Journal Asia on May 27, 2010

Friday, May 21, 2010

Unchecked in India: Political correctness takes giant strides

In Western countries Right-leaning authors, columnists, and commentators often bemoan the cantankerousness and absurdity of political correctness. This is not surprising because PC has become not only an abomination plaguing common parlance and free speech but also a device for the Left to promote its irrationalities and pathologies. In India, however, it is not just the Left but practically all political parties and social organizations that are ardently, and sometime violently, championing PC. At any rate, the casualty is always freedom of expression.
It is seldom that violent PC is successfully checked. In a recent such instance, the country’s Supreme Court came to the rescue of south Indian film actress Khusboo for her statement on pre-marital sex, virginity, and live-in relationships. In an interview in 2005, she had said it was not wrong for women to have pre-marital sex as long as they took precautions. Further, the Tamil actress said, it was “not fair of any educated youth to expect his wife to be a virgin.” She also found nothing objectionable in live-in relationships.
The reaction to her remarks was swift and severe. Many political parties and a few people from the film industry itself castigated her for, what they called, an attack on “Tamil culture and values.” The Dalit Panthers of India (DPI) and another political party, the Pattali Makkal Katchi (PMK), protested against her; the protest often degenerated into violence. But it was not the violent protestors and their instigators who were found on the wrong side of the law; Khushboo, on the other hand, faced more than 20 criminal suits filed against her! One reason was PMK was part of the ruling coalition in New Delhi, with its leader A. Ramadoss being the Health Minister at that time.
Hounded by the law as well as the lawless, Khushboo offered an open apology to Tamils, especially women, saying she would never even dream of sullying the image of the Tamil people. “Even in films, I never undertook roles that lowered the image of women,” she said in a statement. “I have the greatest regard for Tamils, especially Tamil women. If my remarks have hurt anybody’s feelings, I tender an apology. I am one among you and will always remain with you.” But her tormentors were unrelenting.
Her trials and tribulations are likely to end as the Supreme Court has made its sympathy for her quite evident. Its three-judge bench, headed by Chief Justice K.G. Balakrishnan, did not find anything wrong with live-in relationships, incorporating it in Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees the Right to Life with dignity, liberty, and respect.
The relief for Khushboo, however, came after over four years of prosecution, persecution, and vilification. It is interesting to note that the outfits which waged a jihad against her could scarcely be categorized as Rightwing. The DPI claims to be fighting for the Dalits—literally, ‘the oppressed.’ These outcastes were discriminated against in Hindu scriptures. The very name of the party was inspired by that of Black Panther Party of the US. The PMK, too, claims to represent a supposedly ‘backward’ community.
The Khushboo affair underlines not only the threats to the freedom of speech and expression but also the blurring of ideological divisions in India. The parties and groups which are often called Rightist or Right-leaning also promote causes which would elsewhere be considered Leftwing. For instance, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the largest Opposition party for which the terms conservative and nationalist are used, has supported Leftwing measures like increasing the scope of affirmative action and the national rural employment guarantee scheme. All political parties prefer to conform to the dogmas of political discourse, which is clearly Leftist in tone and tenor. The BJP, like other parties, has unquestioningly accepted, even internalized, many premises and principles of the dominant political discourse.
The consequences of ideological straitjacketing have been deplorable. All parties, willy-nilly, end up supporting the causes promoted by the Left: the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005; the reserving one-third seats for women in the Lower House of Parliament and in state Assemblies; the recently notified Right to Education Act; and long goes the list of measures that the Left—though small as far as numbers are concerned—has been able to impose on the nation.
Another group promoting big state measures, and which is often aligned with Leftists or Marxists, comprises political leaders who represent various Dalit or ‘backward’ castes. The ideological straitjacketing is so tight and vicious that even a murmur of protest against any proposal by these parties or leaders is immediately dubbed as anti-poor, anti-Dalit, anti-backward, elitist, etc. Needless to say, reason and commonsense have almost been ostracized from political discourse, which is swayed by sentimentalism.
This brings us to another conspicuous feature of Indian politics: the proclivity of politicians to appeal to the crudest, crassest, and basest of public sentiments. It happens all the time. A Hindi film was named Billu barber; some caste group found the word ‘barber’ offensive. The filmmaker was forced to drop the word ‘barber’ from the name. The lyrics of a Hindi film song had to be changed; Teli ka tel (edible oil made by oil-maker) was replaced by Dilli ka tel (oil from Delhi) because the traditional oil-makers, or Telis, objected to the word. The mere mention of a word denoting a profession becomes politically incorrect.
Pandering to the lowest common denominator has put sanctimoniousness on premium and has made reason a useless virtue; it has also ensured that PC in India fashions a trajectory for itself quite different from that in the West. Spewing gross sentimentalism brings immediate publicity which, in turn, sometimes also translates into political and pecuniary gains. Unsurprisingly, most attacks on the freedom of expression are made on the pretext that the movie, book, etc, “hurt the sentiments” of this or that community.
In the US, there are writers and groups fighting PC; they regularly point out the ludicrousness and menace of PC. In India, PC is wreaking havoc with all political parties—the Leftist, the Rightist, and the Centrist—seeking to capitalize on it.

Others also do it?

If anybody claims that Islamic terror is doctrinally justified (which is a fact), they are confronted with the fallacious argument that other religions are no better. There are portions in the scriptures of Christianity and Hinduism that are not exactly in consonance with the ideas and ideals of the Enlightenment. Since all religions have preached violence—and their adherents have slaughtered non-believers, the blasphemous, and heretics—Islam should not be singled out for doing so. QED.
The fallacy lies essentially in blurring the timeline, misinterpreting the impact of various theologies, and leveling religions. It is true that the scriptures of other religions also preach violence. In the Bible, Lord sanctions the enslaving of strangers or heathens; He also exhorts the faithful to kill anyone who worships a different god .
Similarly, in a famous verse, the sacred Hindu epic, Ramacharitamanas, says, “A drum, a rustic, a Shudra (an outcaste), a beast and a woman—all these deserve to be beaten. Similarly, Manusmriti, the book by the preeminent lawgiver, Manu, makes derogatory remarks about women and Shudras. In short, it is not only Islamic scriptures which preach violence and intensify prejudice; the religious texts of other faiths are no better in this regard.
For centuries, Hindu texts have not only molded legislation and social mores in India—in the same fashion that Christian dogma and prejudice have been the cause of witch-hunts and atrocities on Jews and heretics. In India, religious bias still sometimes results into unspeakable atrocities.
But the point is that today Hindus and Christians are not doing the terrible things that their forebears did in the medieval period. Nor are they demanding that the polity and society should be reorganized according to their religious texts. In the case of Islam, however, such demands are forcefully made—and accepted partially or fully. A large number of Muslims, including many educated and apparently Westernized Muslims, want Shariat to be the fount of jurisprudence.
Worse, liberals compare the atrocities perpetrated by the Hindus and Christians in the medieval period with jihadi terror in the 21st century, and try to show that there is nothing exceptional about such terror.
The fact is that Islamic terror in this day and age is exceptional: while the adherents of other faiths have discarded the distasteful elements of their religions, Muslims refuse to follow suit. A vast majority of them believes that the Koran is the Word of Allah and, therefore, is unalterable. Exegesis has found little space in Islamic theology—at least, till date. Other religions like Hinduism and Christianity have evolved over the centuries. The way Hinduism was practiced in the 14th century—myriad rituals, degradation of Shudras, subjugation of women, elaborate caste rules, rigid customs—is not how it is done today. Ditto with Christianity. It is not that nothing has changed in the Muslim world but the change has come in spite of, not because of, Islam.
Muslim scholars and many non-Muslim experts on Islam do not deny the lack of evolution in the Islamic world, but they refuse to see anything wrong with Islam. For instance, Mohamed Charfi—a Professor of Law in Tunis, Minister for Education (1989-94), a great reformist intellectual who was sentenced to two years' imprisonment—says, “Islam is no less capable of evolution than Christianity or Judaism. But whereas, over the past few centuries, Europeans have undergone profound technological, economic, cultural and political changes, often amid considerable suffering and with major ebbs and flows, the Muslim peoples have fallen greatly behind in all spheres. This is not a fate to which they are doomed for ever; it is possible for them to close the gap.”
The unwillingness to look beyond the “technological, economic, cultural and political” factors, the reluctance to examine Islamic theology is at the root of problem. Hinduism, Christianity, and other religions have been subjected to thorough scholarly scrutiny. The loathsome practice of female feticide is (rightly) attributed to certain Hindu beliefs. But when it comes to Islam… well, we have to be careful.
Then there is the issue of religions leveling. Well-known Islamic scholar Karen Armstrong wrote, “Every fundamentalist movement I’ve studied in Judaism, Christianity and Islam is convinced at some gut, visceral level that secular liberal society wants to wipe out religion.”
Notice the dangerous syllogism. All fundamentalist movements are illiberal; Islamic fundamentalism is also illiberal; ergo, it is no worse than other fundamentalist movements. The danger lies in confusing the magnitudes: Hindu and Christian fundamentalists might have been involved a few, sporadic violent incidents, but neither the scale and scope has been as vast as evident in the case of jihadis nor the level of organization and commitment as exhibited by al-Qaeda.
The entire Muslim and liberal enterprise is oriented around the unexamined axiom that the violence by jihadis is not about Islam. But, as Salman Rushdie said in a famous post-9/11 article, this is about Islam.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Rule by law: Delhi minister harasses hotel

Delhi’s Social Welfare & Labour Minister Mangat Ram Singhal’s vindictiveness against a five-star hotel demonstrates how government agencies are used and abused by politicians to serve their personal ends.
The security staff of the hotel committed the cardinal sin of checking Singhal’s car. Since most politicians consider themselves as above law, the honorable got so furious. So, he unleashed eight inspectors on the hotel. Even by the standards of Indian politics, the display of might was so disgraceful that Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit felt ashamed. She decided to rein in the wayward minister and his men. She reprimanded Singhal; she also pulled up senior officers of the departments involved such as Labour, Excise, Health, Finance, Prevention of Food Adulteration and Electrical. She is said to have castigated the officers for “wasting government resources” and ordered them to apologise to the hotel individually.
It was a big hotel, run by a leading company. The ill-treatment meted out to it was righted by a sensible chief minister. One wonders about the plight of smaller enterprises which are always at the mercy of our political masters and the paraphernalia that they have under them to dictate terms.
This is not the rule of law; this is the rule by law. Aristotle favored the rule of law, writing that “law should govern”; those in power should be “servants of the laws.”
One of the prerequisites of modern democracy is the rule of law. A prominent political scientist, Li Shuguang, illuminates us by distinguishing the rule of law by the rule by law. “The difference.... is that under the rule of law the law is preeminent and can serve as a check against the abuse of power. Under rule by law, the law can serve as a mere tool for a government that suppresses in a legalistic fashion.”
The Singhal episode clearly shows that we have the rule by law. It has also highlighted the fact that the government officials are putty in the hands of politicians. A few days ago, the then Indian Premier League Commissioner, Lalit Modi, was interrogated by officials. The timing made it all obvious: it came just after his well-publicized fight with former minister of state for external affairs Shashi Tharoor. The high and mighty in New Delhi were offended: how could an upstart cricket czar take on one of us. So, the empire struck back. Unfortunately, non-Congress regimes have been equally bad on this count. The Atal Bihari Vajpayee government, for instance, vengefully persecuted and prosecuted the promoters and financiers of Tehelka after the Bangaru Laxman affair.
The politicians are unlikely to promote the rule of law. We, the people of India, will have to do that.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Enemies of pleasure

The puritan, wrote Thomas B Macaulay, hated bear baiting, not because it gave pain to the bear, but because it gave pleasure to the spectators. There are not many puritans in India in the literal sense of the word—that is, a significant grouping of English-speaking Protestants in the 16th and 17th-century. But the puritanical spirit is ubiquitous in our political class. Our netas are aghast that people are having fun. Make no mistake about it: they are not scandalized because a minister has been found involved in financial irregularities—Shashi Tharoor is not the first minister to have faced such accusations and, unfortunately, would not be the last one; they are outraged that something so glitzy and glamorous has become so popular. Rockstar status of cricketers, jazzy cheerleaders, dance and drama, the entire nation glued to TV sets—how could the people be allowed to have so much pleasure? So, senior Congress leader and Overseas Indians Minister Vayalar Ravi feels that the Indian Premier League is “glorified gambling.” Communist Party of India (CPI) MP Gurudas Dasgupta made is clear that the Tharoor episode was just tangential. “The minister’s resignation is not the issue. The issue is the IPL... (The) issue is laundering of money. All this is happening under the nose of the Government of India… Cricket is being maligned in the country. Wrong message is given to the budding cricketers to join the Twenty20 and earn crores.”
Then there was also the Yadav triumvirate—Lalu Prasad (RJD), Mulayam Singh Yadav (SP) and Sharad Yadav (JD-U). They want the Government to disband the IPL which has become a “betting and gambling ring.” Sharad Yadav alleged that IPL was “vulgar” and a “den of vices, black money and loot.” Notice how vague allegations—at least at the time when such remarks were made in Parliament—have been blindly accepted as gospel truth. Also notice the sermonizing by the leaders who do not have even an iota of regard for democracy, Parliamentary decorum, and decency—as evident from their words and deeds over the Women’s Reservation Bill. Yet another point to be noticed is the broad consensus across the political and ideological spectrum; everybody is railing against a sporting event that is lapped up by the people. Do the politicians fear that the IPL phenomenon would undermine their own popularity? Well, IPL cannot hurt the prospects of politicians. So, are our political masters angry just because the people love IPL? This seems to be more likely, because there is a strong moralizing streak in our netas; they prefer carefully laid-out prescriptions and proscriptions. Quite evidently, the IPL entertainment flouts doesn’t give a damn to the preachy sermons of our political masters. Perhaps, this enrages them.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Human rights groups: Maoists’ B-team

That human rights groups often act as B-team or over-ground operatives of Maoists is becoming increasingly evident. Often, the sympathies, if not affiliations, become obvious. A few recent statements by human rights champions smack of their ideological leanings.
People’s Union for Democratic Rights, Delhi (PUDR) secretary Gautam Navlakha wrote in The Economic Times (February 26), that the war against CPI (Maoist) should “be replaced by dialogue... The war on Maoists is not because they want to overthrow the presently-constituted Indian state—they have been trying that for nearly half a century.
“And, according to senior Maoist leaders themselves, it will take another 50-60 years to succeed. Besides, at present, in the PM’s words, the Maoists possess ‘modest capabilities.’ Nor is it because of their wanton acts of violence. The record of parliamentary parties, in varying degree of culpability, is not better, if not worse.”
Notice the audacity implicit in Navlakha’s candor: he makes no bones about the ultimate goal of the Maoists, that is, destruction of Indian democracy. Notice also the subterfuge: since the Maoists’ combat capabilities are modest, India should not take them seriously. We should fight them only after 50-60 years when they are ready! It is like saying that I should ignore my enemy who has sworn to kill me just because he is weak at this point of time! Let him strengthen himself, and then I should take him on—to get slaughtered at his hands!
And, of course, there is moral equivalence: the Maoists indulge in “wanton acts of violence,” but “the record of parliamentary parties, in varying degree of culpability, is not better, if not worse.” Such attitude is the hallmark of all arguments posited by Leftists and liberals
“Civil rights activists oppose war against our own people because political aspirations ought not to be suppressed militarily,” wrote Navlakha. Well, the Maoists are not “our own people”; they are the people of Mao. Therefore, they believe in the Great Helmsman’s dictum that power flows from the barrel of the gun. Those who live by the gun should not be complaining if they face superior firepower. And, at any rate, “political aspirations” are different from totalitarian intentions.
Unfortunately, Navlakha is not the only purveyor of lies; there are a large number of people, some of them public figures, who are compulsively mendacious. On March 1, some of them called a press conference to lament that the Indian state has turned monstrous in its war on Maoists (which, these worthies believe, is actually a war against tribals). Human rights activists, journalists and fact-finding committees were being targeted, advocate Prashant Bhushan alleged.
“The government has done little for the tribals and now they are trying to snatch their land. When tribals agitate peacefully, the State security forces descend on them, harass them and burn their villages. About 700 villages have been burnt in the past two years in Chhattisgarh. People are bound to protest and take up arms. For every 100 Maoists eliminated, thousands are created through collateral damage,” Bhushan said.
Notice the chicanery: the campaign against murderous Maoists has been transmogrified into a war against tribals. Of course, no evidence is given to support the outlandish claim. And those of Bhushan’s ilk will never accept that the Maoists are ruthlessly killing tribals in Chhattisgarh.
At the press conference, Justice Rajinder Sachar (Retd) was also present. This man is the embodiment of all that is ossified in India. An inveterate sympathizer of terrorists, he earned eternal disgrace for himself by heading a committee on Muslims and recommending boundless appeasement. He said: “The state cannot be a terrorist. It is the ultimate repository of law and order. Talks should happen between the government and the Maoists in an open atmosphere where there is no fear. Both sides should cease hostilities for dialogue to take place.”
The Navalakhas, the Bhushans, and the Sachars always tell us to embrace those who kill us. Pakistanis send jihadis to bomb our cities and slaughter our citizens, but we should continue to hold talks with Islamabad. The Maoists gun down our security personnel and liquidate the common citizens not falling in line—as the brave tribals in Chhattisgarh—but “talks should happen between the government and the Maoists.”
And, by the way, Mr. Sachar, which “both sides” are you talking about? Can the thuggish Maoists by any stretch of imagination be equated with the security personnel? On the one side are the followers of the world’s greatest butcher, Mao; on the other side are the soldiers of the biggest democracy. What is the comparison? Such moral equivalence just shows Sachar’s own moral bankruptcy and intellectual hollowness.
It is time the media and other opinion-makers exposed the duplicity and insidiousness of the so-called human rights activists.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

The only good Taliban is dead Taliban

Who chopped off the heads of Sikhs in the North-West province of Pakistan because they refused to convert to Islam? Is it the ‘good Taliban’—with whom US President Barack Obama, UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown and other world leaders want to do business?
I wonder how Obama, always soft on jihadis, would even describe the outrage. Under him, the Pentagon’s Quadrennial Defense Review and the Quadrennial Homeland Security Review have practically banned the use of words ‘Muslim’ or ‘Islam.’ Obamaspeak is likely to call the murderers as ‘violent extremist,’ and not jihadis, lest it hurts the sentiments of the people who follow ‘the religion of peace.’
The Taliban unleash a reign of terror, murder at will, terrorize religious minorities, subjugate women, suppress any dissenting voice, and want to herd the entire world to medieval barbarity. And what does the international community, led by the US—supposedly the champion of liberty, pluralism and democracy—do? Well, it timidly accepts Taliban ruthlessness. It even intends to buy peace, offering hundreds of millions of dollars to them, as it did at the recently held London conference to ensure their comeback.
And what does India do? Typically, it issues strong statements. “We condemn this barbaric act of Taliban who have taken into custody three of the Indian nationals. The message that I have received which needs to be updated is that one has been done away with and other two are kept under captivation,” External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna said.
Minister of State for External Affairs Parneet Kaur offered running commentary: “Last time, Sikhs were threatened to pay Jazia and Pakistan had said it is its internal matter, I appeal to Pakistan to take strict action.” Appeal to Pakistan? Did we get it right? New Delhi would appeal to those who unleashed the Taliban on the world in the first place? Could the tragedy become more farcical?
The politicians of India should get real. They should comprehend the vileness of Taliban. They should also beware of the duplicity of Islamabad.
Our leaders have failed miserably in convincing the world capitals that Pakistan’s support to the West’s war on terror is phony. Even now it is not late. India should highlight the fact that the evil Pakistan has spawned is a menace to all, and that the only good Taliban are dead Taliban.