With India facing grievous terror threat from the Maoists (or Naxalites) and jihadis, one would have expected the powers to be getting their act together to fight the mortal enemies of the nation. But, alas, that was not to be! Our political masters are not serious about the war on terror.
Consider the case of Railway Minister and Trinamool Congress Mamata Banerjee. Her ties with Maoists are no secret; in fact, she benefited because of her relations with the Naxalites in the last general elections. Her relations with the ultras adversely affected last year’s operations against them at Lalgarh.
Now, she has reportedly forced the Union Cabinet to drop from the Presidential address to the joint session of Parliament a condemnation of the murderous Naxal strike on the EFR camp at Silda in the West Midnapore district in West Bengal on February 15. Monday, which left 24 jawans dead and many injured. At the insistence of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, the Cabinet nevertheless agreed to include a general condemnation of Maoist attacks all over the country in recent months.
“What is the proof that the attack was carried out by Maoists? If at all, it appears to be the handiwork of CPM. I would urge the Prime Minister to first order an inquiry into the incident,” Mamata reportedly told her Cabinet colleagues.
In our times, the merchants of falsehood find refuge in the what-is-the-proof line of argumentation. This comes handy when one is promoting any vile cause, be it Naxalism or jihad. What is the proof that the young Muslim men killed at Batla House in Delhi in September 2008 were terrorists, cry jihadis, their sympathizers, pro-jihadi human rights groups, and pink punks. It was a fake encounter and there should be an inquiry into it, they thunder.
It is pointed out that the Batla House shootout could not have been fake because Delhi Police lost an ace officer, Inspector M.C. Sharma in it. What kind of fake encounter was it in which a cop loses his life? But the peddlers of lies persist with their demand for in inquiry.
The National Human Rights Commission probed into the matter, and reports to the Delhi High Court that the shootout was genuine. But the human rights mafia still was not satisfied. The Supreme Court looked into the matter, and it also gave a clean chit to Delhi Police.
The screaming by human rights mafia could have been ignored had it not been supported by, among others, many politicians, the most important of them being Congress general secretary Digvijay Singh. He was sympathetic to the cause upheld by the human rights mafia. He even visited Azamgarh, the UP district which has shot into notoriety because of being the hub of so many Islamic terrorists.
It is not that only the ruling coalition is lackadaisical in its attitude towards Maoists and jihadis, the Bharatiya Janata Party is little better. The saffron leaders spew fiery rhetoric when talking about terrorists, but they are willing to match practice with precept. In Jharkhand, they are in power, but have no problems with Chief Minister Shibu Soren’s soft approach towards Naxalites.
The Maoists and jihadis murder our citizens, shoot down our security personnel, bomb our cities, and want to establish a reign of terror. And our netas sympathize with them! The question to be asked in India is not whether we would win the war against terror, but whether our politicians are even willing to fight that war all earnestness.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Saturday, February 13, 2010
Jairam Ramesh bows to green terror
The merchants of mendacity have scored a big victory by forcing Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh to place an indefinite “moratorium” on the introduction of a genetically-modified brinjal. His colleague in the Council of Ministers, Kapil Sibal, was candid enough to say that Ramesh “bowed to populism.”
This was yet another case of green terrorists abusing science to promote their Luddite and socialist agendas. Years after Centre for Science and Environment chief Sunita Narain carried out her deceitful tirade against cola companies, and weeks after IPCC boss R.K. Pachauri was exposed for running his shop by peddling voodoo science, we have a situation in which India science has faced a setback. The country’s top apex technical committee, the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) has been ignored because a bunch of econuts clamored against an innovation in the farm sector.
To be fair to Ramesh, he did not have much of a choice. Protest against Bt brinjal was quite widespread. The RSS—never comfortable with science and modernity and too willing to accept Left shibboleths—spoke against Bt brinjal. The ban on the innovation in the BJP-ruled Uttarakhand, Karnataka and Himachal Pradesh was a logical culmination. At the same time, green loonies who run myriad non-governmental organizations (NGOs) already were screaming.
Ramesh claimed that “sentiment was negative” at the public hearings in seven cities. Sentiment? Is science run by sentiments? And, by the way, whose sentiments?
Dr. M Mahadevappa, a two-time former vice-chancellor of the University of Agriculture Sciences, Dharwad, who attended the public hearing in Bangalore, was quoted in The Indian Express, “I was out-shouted by the NGO lobbies the moment I began speaking. I could not express my views. Public hearings of the sort that were arranged are not the right place where scientific issues can be discussed in an objective manner.”
The UAS, Dharwad, and the Tamil Nadu Agriculture University, Coimbatore, actively collaborated in developing Bt Brinjal.
“I have been working with several Krishi Vigyan Kendras in Karnataka for several years and I have found no opposition from farmers against Bt brinjal. Even at the Bangalore meeting, I was opposed by the NGOs and not by the farmers,” Dr. Mahadevappa said.
Dr. B.C. Viraktamath, project director at the Directorate of Rice Research in Hyderabad, was not even allowed to enter the building where the hearing was going on. “The way the consultations were held, it was very clear that the entire exercise was random with a disproportionate representation of protestors,” he said.
Another scientist, Dr. M. Sujatha, of the Directorate of Oilseeds Research at Hyderabad, said, “This is not the right kind of approach to solicit views on such a complex issue. The minister could have held separate meetings with scientists, farmers and NGOs to get a more balanced and clear picture.”
Chengal Reddy, a farmers’ leader, questioned the representativeness of protestors. “Who is this ‘general public’? The general public had even opposed computers when they were first launched.”
Actually, it is the mafia of NGOs, sundry pink punks, and green terrorists who make so much noise that they are often assumed to be the representatives of people. The truth, however, is that these busybodies are just promoting their vile, retrograde agenda in the name of championing the cause of public.
This was yet another case of green terrorists abusing science to promote their Luddite and socialist agendas. Years after Centre for Science and Environment chief Sunita Narain carried out her deceitful tirade against cola companies, and weeks after IPCC boss R.K. Pachauri was exposed for running his shop by peddling voodoo science, we have a situation in which India science has faced a setback. The country’s top apex technical committee, the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) has been ignored because a bunch of econuts clamored against an innovation in the farm sector.
To be fair to Ramesh, he did not have much of a choice. Protest against Bt brinjal was quite widespread. The RSS—never comfortable with science and modernity and too willing to accept Left shibboleths—spoke against Bt brinjal. The ban on the innovation in the BJP-ruled Uttarakhand, Karnataka and Himachal Pradesh was a logical culmination. At the same time, green loonies who run myriad non-governmental organizations (NGOs) already were screaming.
Ramesh claimed that “sentiment was negative” at the public hearings in seven cities. Sentiment? Is science run by sentiments? And, by the way, whose sentiments?
Dr. M Mahadevappa, a two-time former vice-chancellor of the University of Agriculture Sciences, Dharwad, who attended the public hearing in Bangalore, was quoted in The Indian Express, “I was out-shouted by the NGO lobbies the moment I began speaking. I could not express my views. Public hearings of the sort that were arranged are not the right place where scientific issues can be discussed in an objective manner.”
The UAS, Dharwad, and the Tamil Nadu Agriculture University, Coimbatore, actively collaborated in developing Bt Brinjal.
“I have been working with several Krishi Vigyan Kendras in Karnataka for several years and I have found no opposition from farmers against Bt brinjal. Even at the Bangalore meeting, I was opposed by the NGOs and not by the farmers,” Dr. Mahadevappa said.
Dr. B.C. Viraktamath, project director at the Directorate of Rice Research in Hyderabad, was not even allowed to enter the building where the hearing was going on. “The way the consultations were held, it was very clear that the entire exercise was random with a disproportionate representation of protestors,” he said.
Another scientist, Dr. M. Sujatha, of the Directorate of Oilseeds Research at Hyderabad, said, “This is not the right kind of approach to solicit views on such a complex issue. The minister could have held separate meetings with scientists, farmers and NGOs to get a more balanced and clear picture.”
Chengal Reddy, a farmers’ leader, questioned the representativeness of protestors. “Who is this ‘general public’? The general public had even opposed computers when they were first launched.”
Actually, it is the mafia of NGOs, sundry pink punks, and green terrorists who make so much noise that they are often assumed to be the representatives of people. The truth, however, is that these busybodies are just promoting their vile, retrograde agenda in the name of championing the cause of public.
Saturday, February 6, 2010
Manipulating media: Rahul’s spin doctors do good job
Hero worship in India has always been a big problem. Now, it is becoming much bigger, thanks to the people’s reluctance to ask questions. Idolatry is so rampant that they even start worshipping those who have little to do heroism. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi’s recent deification is a case in point.
Consider the facts. His party is in power in New Delhi and Bombay. Yet, for over two years, in Bombay and other parts of Maharashtra, a rabidly parochial outfit, the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), has been physically assaulting north Indians and inciting violence against them. Its older cousin, the Shiv Sena, has been doing that for a longer period. But these goons go scot-free. MNS legislators even had the temerity to manhandle a fellow MLA on the floor of the House. But neither the leaders who instigate violence nor the activists of the two parties are brought to book.
In fact, the Congress sought to, and did, benefit from the terror tactics of MNS chief Raj Thackeray. All these years, Rahul Gandhi did nothing to stop the hooliganism of Sena and MNS. A few days ago, suddenly, he—or perhaps his media managers and spin doctors—woke up to the chauvinism of the Thackerays. Of, it is so bad! How these thugs can say that Bombay is only for the people of the state? Mumbai is for all, thundered Rahul in the presence of the press. An obsequies media gave him a loud applause for uttering a truism. And the applause keeps growing by the hour.
Rahul goes to Bombay—and the media portrays this as heroic as Lord Ram’s invasion of Ravan’s Lanka. He is glorified for going to Bombay, for riding the local train, for uttering inanities, for everything he does. But few, if any, slam him for what he does not do—that is, not goading his own party and government to take action against the felony of the Thackerays.
The newspaper headlines scream: ‘In Mumbai, Rahul takes local line, derails Sena gameplan,’ ‘Rahul takes the Dadar Fast to make his Mumbai point,’ ‘Congress resolves to take on Shiv Sena.’ We are made to believe that a redeemer is at work, a deliverer would come to the rescue of the hapless victims of the evil Bal Thackeray and Raj Thackeray. But we are not told that the evil is a creation of Rahul’s party. It is like Bhinderanwale redux: the Congress created the monster, and then reaped political windfall by vanquishing him.
All this is very clever. It is indeed the sterling success of Congress media managers that the almost all newspapers and channels have become Rahul’s hagiographers. But there is no statesmanship involved in manipulating media and molding public mood. Nor is there any heroism in fooling people.
Consider the facts. His party is in power in New Delhi and Bombay. Yet, for over two years, in Bombay and other parts of Maharashtra, a rabidly parochial outfit, the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), has been physically assaulting north Indians and inciting violence against them. Its older cousin, the Shiv Sena, has been doing that for a longer period. But these goons go scot-free. MNS legislators even had the temerity to manhandle a fellow MLA on the floor of the House. But neither the leaders who instigate violence nor the activists of the two parties are brought to book.
In fact, the Congress sought to, and did, benefit from the terror tactics of MNS chief Raj Thackeray. All these years, Rahul Gandhi did nothing to stop the hooliganism of Sena and MNS. A few days ago, suddenly, he—or perhaps his media managers and spin doctors—woke up to the chauvinism of the Thackerays. Of, it is so bad! How these thugs can say that Bombay is only for the people of the state? Mumbai is for all, thundered Rahul in the presence of the press. An obsequies media gave him a loud applause for uttering a truism. And the applause keeps growing by the hour.
Rahul goes to Bombay—and the media portrays this as heroic as Lord Ram’s invasion of Ravan’s Lanka. He is glorified for going to Bombay, for riding the local train, for uttering inanities, for everything he does. But few, if any, slam him for what he does not do—that is, not goading his own party and government to take action against the felony of the Thackerays.
The newspaper headlines scream: ‘In Mumbai, Rahul takes local line, derails Sena gameplan,’ ‘Rahul takes the Dadar Fast to make his Mumbai point,’ ‘Congress resolves to take on Shiv Sena.’ We are made to believe that a redeemer is at work, a deliverer would come to the rescue of the hapless victims of the evil Bal Thackeray and Raj Thackeray. But we are not told that the evil is a creation of Rahul’s party. It is like Bhinderanwale redux: the Congress created the monster, and then reaped political windfall by vanquishing him.
All this is very clever. It is indeed the sterling success of Congress media managers that the almost all newspapers and channels have become Rahul’s hagiographers. But there is no statesmanship involved in manipulating media and molding public mood. Nor is there any heroism in fooling people.
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Triumph of evil: Pakistan calls shots in Afghanistan
International relations are often bereft of morality, but in these politically correct times they are also without commonsense and reason. Nothing else explains the newfound assertiveness of Pakistan in matters as disparate as cricket and Afghanistan.
The Pakistanis have forced the Indian Premier League (IPL) to shun its unspoken no-Pak-player stand. In fact, they have made it appear as if the Pak cricketers have boycotted IPL! Pakistan Cricket Board chairman Ejaz Butt has revoked the no-objection certificates granted to it players earlier. Butt said, “No Pakistan player will play in IPL this year. The insulting manner in which Pakistan players have been treated will not be tolerated.” Earlier, he had the temerity to seek “an apology from IPL.”
More dangerous and revolting is Islamabad’s audacity in matters related to Afghanistan. Worse, the audacity has paid rich dividends. The recent one-day international conference on Afghanistan on January 28 was testimony of Pakistan’s success in international politics. World powers were goaded to accept the oxymoronic concept of ‘good Taliban’ and buy peace with the barbarous thugs. For this purpose, British Prime Minister Gordon Brown—hosting the conference with Afghan President Hamid Karzai and UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon—announced the setting up of a $500-million “trust fund.” A report in The Times Of India (January 29) said, “As a goodwill gesture, the conference was preceded by a lifting of United Nations sanctions on five leaders of the obscurantist Taliban regime, which was ousted by armed forces led by the United States after the 9/11 attack on New York by the Afghanistan-based Al Qaida. Among the beneficiaries is a former foreign minister Wakil Ahmad Muttawakil.” It may be recalled that Muttawakil was a chum of the hijackers of IC-814. He is said to have helped them unload their baggage from the aircraft in Kandahar; he also negotiated on their behalf. He is among the once off the UN sanctions list to “facilitate” the reconciliation.
Needless to say, Pakistan is the chief supporter and beneficiary of the treacherous concept of good Taliban. In an interview to a British daily, its Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi said, “Pakistan is perhaps better placed than any other country in the world to support Afghan reintegration and reconciliation.” Of course, “Afghan reintegration and reconciliation” will resuscitate the cronies of Mullah Omar, the uncrowned Caliph of Afghanistan before the George Bush-led US ousted them from Kabul.
According to the TOI report, External Affairs Minister S.M. “Krishna was allocated a seat in the second of three rows of attendees at the conference which in itself reflected India's peripheral role in Afghan affairs in the eyes of the international community. This, despite India being the biggest regional aid-giver to Afghanistan, with a commitment of $1.3 million. Earlier in the week, Turkey, an ally of Pakistan, did not even bother to invite India to a confabulation on Afghanistan.”
Pakistan—which is the cause of much of misery of Afghans (and of others)—is calling the shots. Even literally. It has reported told the Americans that it would not tolerate India’s bigger role in Pashtun areas like Kandahar and Jalalabad and in the rest of the country. Islamabad likes to say that only Afghanistan’s “contiguous neighbors” can be allowed to participate in any “regional” mechanism. Pakistani newspapers have reported that the Pakistan army and the ISI have decided that only they would decide on the Afghan matters.
Notice the irony and the tragedy. The good work India has done in reconstruction in the war-torn nation is globally acknowledged. A recent study commissioned by three major Western—a British, an American and a German—broadcasters found that 71 per cent of the Afghan population favored a big role by India. Yet, India has little role to play today in Afghanistan.
The facts hint at a Sadean comedy in which evil triumphs and good is vanquished. The wide world knows Pakistan’s nefarious role in creating, nurturing, and arming the Taliban, aiding and abetting terrorist groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba, and supporting al-Qaeda. Among others, President A.A. Zardari and his predecessor, Gen Pervez Musharraf, have admitted to government assistance to jihadis. Yet, it gets rewarded for felony and duplicity.
I wonder what happened to the multi-pronged war on terror that the US has wage for over eight years. Why couldn’t the world’s mightiest nation, which has the support of almost all other countries in this endeavor, check the flow of money and arms to the jihadis? Is it some conspiracy of cosmic proportions, funded by petrodollars? And is that funding even more powerful than the military prowess and political clout of the world’s wealthiest nation? Such stuff seems straight from a Robert Ludlum novel, but this could be true. After all, truth is often stranger than fiction.
The Pakistanis have forced the Indian Premier League (IPL) to shun its unspoken no-Pak-player stand. In fact, they have made it appear as if the Pak cricketers have boycotted IPL! Pakistan Cricket Board chairman Ejaz Butt has revoked the no-objection certificates granted to it players earlier. Butt said, “No Pakistan player will play in IPL this year. The insulting manner in which Pakistan players have been treated will not be tolerated.” Earlier, he had the temerity to seek “an apology from IPL.”
More dangerous and revolting is Islamabad’s audacity in matters related to Afghanistan. Worse, the audacity has paid rich dividends. The recent one-day international conference on Afghanistan on January 28 was testimony of Pakistan’s success in international politics. World powers were goaded to accept the oxymoronic concept of ‘good Taliban’ and buy peace with the barbarous thugs. For this purpose, British Prime Minister Gordon Brown—hosting the conference with Afghan President Hamid Karzai and UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon—announced the setting up of a $500-million “trust fund.” A report in The Times Of India (January 29) said, “As a goodwill gesture, the conference was preceded by a lifting of United Nations sanctions on five leaders of the obscurantist Taliban regime, which was ousted by armed forces led by the United States after the 9/11 attack on New York by the Afghanistan-based Al Qaida. Among the beneficiaries is a former foreign minister Wakil Ahmad Muttawakil.” It may be recalled that Muttawakil was a chum of the hijackers of IC-814. He is said to have helped them unload their baggage from the aircraft in Kandahar; he also negotiated on their behalf. He is among the once off the UN sanctions list to “facilitate” the reconciliation.
Needless to say, Pakistan is the chief supporter and beneficiary of the treacherous concept of good Taliban. In an interview to a British daily, its Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi said, “Pakistan is perhaps better placed than any other country in the world to support Afghan reintegration and reconciliation.” Of course, “Afghan reintegration and reconciliation” will resuscitate the cronies of Mullah Omar, the uncrowned Caliph of Afghanistan before the George Bush-led US ousted them from Kabul.
According to the TOI report, External Affairs Minister S.M. “Krishna was allocated a seat in the second of three rows of attendees at the conference which in itself reflected India's peripheral role in Afghan affairs in the eyes of the international community. This, despite India being the biggest regional aid-giver to Afghanistan, with a commitment of $1.3 million. Earlier in the week, Turkey, an ally of Pakistan, did not even bother to invite India to a confabulation on Afghanistan.”
Pakistan—which is the cause of much of misery of Afghans (and of others)—is calling the shots. Even literally. It has reported told the Americans that it would not tolerate India’s bigger role in Pashtun areas like Kandahar and Jalalabad and in the rest of the country. Islamabad likes to say that only Afghanistan’s “contiguous neighbors” can be allowed to participate in any “regional” mechanism. Pakistani newspapers have reported that the Pakistan army and the ISI have decided that only they would decide on the Afghan matters.
Notice the irony and the tragedy. The good work India has done in reconstruction in the war-torn nation is globally acknowledged. A recent study commissioned by three major Western—a British, an American and a German—broadcasters found that 71 per cent of the Afghan population favored a big role by India. Yet, India has little role to play today in Afghanistan.
The facts hint at a Sadean comedy in which evil triumphs and good is vanquished. The wide world knows Pakistan’s nefarious role in creating, nurturing, and arming the Taliban, aiding and abetting terrorist groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba, and supporting al-Qaeda. Among others, President A.A. Zardari and his predecessor, Gen Pervez Musharraf, have admitted to government assistance to jihadis. Yet, it gets rewarded for felony and duplicity.
I wonder what happened to the multi-pronged war on terror that the US has wage for over eight years. Why couldn’t the world’s mightiest nation, which has the support of almost all other countries in this endeavor, check the flow of money and arms to the jihadis? Is it some conspiracy of cosmic proportions, funded by petrodollars? And is that funding even more powerful than the military prowess and political clout of the world’s wealthiest nation? Such stuff seems straight from a Robert Ludlum novel, but this could be true. After all, truth is often stranger than fiction.
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Dumping reason: Chidambaram slams Pak players’ exclusion from IPL
Home Minister P Chidambaram’s statement on the exclusion of Pakistani cricketers from the third edition of the Indian Premier League (IPL) is unfortunate, for this largely undoes the good work began by IPL bosses. The big guns of industry and cinema had rightly given a snub to the Pakistanis, and just to the Pak cricketers. It is a well-known fact that this is a nation whose state, military, and society support and lionize the bloodthirsty jihadis. The Indian Government should have tried to make Pakistan a pariah state by highlighting this fact but, thanks to Muslim appeasement and a pusillanimous foreign policy, it has not done so. Worse, when some private individuals attempted to take a step in that direction, the ruling United Progressive Alliance is resisting it.
“I think it is a disservice to cricket that some of these players were not picked. I don’t know why the IPL teams acted in the manner they acted. But certainly to suggest that there was a hint or nudge from the government is completely untrue,” Chidambaram told a news channel a week after the auction where all the Pak players were ignored.
It may be “a disservice to cricket” if the world T20 champions are ignore in an event, but it is surely a service to mankind to stigmatize the citizens of a country whose state and society nurture and glorify mass-murderers; there is no other way to describe jihadis. The world needs to boycott the Pakistanis to force them promote terror. It was international pressure which played a big part in goading South Africa to end the reprehensible apartheid policy. By the way, this policy in no way hurt anybody outside South Africa. Now that Islamic terror has become a threat to peace all over the world, there is no reason why the Pakistan, the engine house of jihad, should be treated with kid gloves.
Regrettably, Chidambaram’s views are shared by others as well. Shah Rukh Khan, who owns Kolkata Knight Riders, is also unhappy about the exclusion of Pak players. He said, “I truly believe they [Pakistan players] should have been chosen.” A few days ago, Surjit S. Bhalla, a liberal intellectual, lamented about the exclusion of Pak players. He wrote in Business Standard on January 23, “The politicians believe that after the terror attacks of last year, the popular public wants to punish all Pakistanis, regardless of race, color, or religion. Even if the public thinks that way, does it make sense for the government to cater to such base instincts?”
The problem with liberals like Bhalla is that they dogmatically stick to their beliefs which have been disproved by facts. If the public wants all Pakistanis to be punished, it is not the result of any “base instincts” but of commonsense and reason. Sadly, liberals have bid adieu to commonsense and reason. What is sadder is that the powers that be tend to follow the liberal rather than the reasonable viewpoint.
“I think it is a disservice to cricket that some of these players were not picked. I don’t know why the IPL teams acted in the manner they acted. But certainly to suggest that there was a hint or nudge from the government is completely untrue,” Chidambaram told a news channel a week after the auction where all the Pak players were ignored.
It may be “a disservice to cricket” if the world T20 champions are ignore in an event, but it is surely a service to mankind to stigmatize the citizens of a country whose state and society nurture and glorify mass-murderers; there is no other way to describe jihadis. The world needs to boycott the Pakistanis to force them promote terror. It was international pressure which played a big part in goading South Africa to end the reprehensible apartheid policy. By the way, this policy in no way hurt anybody outside South Africa. Now that Islamic terror has become a threat to peace all over the world, there is no reason why the Pakistan, the engine house of jihad, should be treated with kid gloves.
Regrettably, Chidambaram’s views are shared by others as well. Shah Rukh Khan, who owns Kolkata Knight Riders, is also unhappy about the exclusion of Pak players. He said, “I truly believe they [Pakistan players] should have been chosen.” A few days ago, Surjit S. Bhalla, a liberal intellectual, lamented about the exclusion of Pak players. He wrote in Business Standard on January 23, “The politicians believe that after the terror attacks of last year, the popular public wants to punish all Pakistanis, regardless of race, color, or religion. Even if the public thinks that way, does it make sense for the government to cater to such base instincts?”
The problem with liberals like Bhalla is that they dogmatically stick to their beliefs which have been disproved by facts. If the public wants all Pakistanis to be punished, it is not the result of any “base instincts” but of commonsense and reason. Sadly, liberals have bid adieu to commonsense and reason. What is sadder is that the powers that be tend to follow the liberal rather than the reasonable viewpoint.
Monday, November 16, 2009
Climate of opinion needs to change
We are fond of calling out country as the oldest living civilization. But what kind of civilization is this that tolerates violence in the name of supposedly hallowed regional pride? What kind of democracy is India if the country’s biggest cinema icon, Amitabh Bachchan, is humiliated by the thuggish Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) and a great cricketer, Sachin Tendulkar, is snubbed by the equally thuggish Shiv Sena?
And what kind of climate of opinion we are condemned to suffer? It could not get more polluted. It is indeed a testimony of the rottenness of public debate that the indubitable criminality of Raj Thackeray and his MNS has been bestowed a semblance of respectability. A few things are manifestly true. The MNS legislators assaulted Samajwadi Party legislator Abu Azmi inside the Maharashtra Assembly because he insisted on taking oath in Hindi. They were ordered or instigated to do so by Raj. The MNS chief had said before the oath-taking ceremony, “If any MLA does not take oath in Marathi, the House will see what happens.”
The offenders have not denied the assault; at any rate, there is television footage which has recorded the outrage. Yet, nothing substantial has been done to punish the wrong-doers; they have been barred from the Assembly for four years, but this is not commensurate with the offence, which is much graver. Further, an unnecessary language debate has begun, engendering meaningless questions and issues. Is it wrong to take oath in the nation language, Hindi? Should a legislator speak only the language of his state? Did Azmi intend to demean Marathi? The chatter is endless; and this endlessness ends up fading the felony: that is, physical violence against a legislator on the floor of the House.
Worse, politicians of other parties have jumped in the fray—not to establish the rule of law but to make political capital. Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray had the brazenness to castigate cricket icon Sachin Tendulkar for the latter’s comment: “Mumbai belongs to India. That is how I look at it. And I am a Maharashtrian and I am extremely proud of that but I am an Indian first.” Bal Thackeray wrote in the Sena mouthpiece Saamna, “There was no need for him to take a cheeky single by making such remarks.” Well, Mr Thackeray, Tendulkar does not need any cheeky singles; he has done pretty well both on the ground and off it to score a brownie point. He did not make any political statement; he stated a geographical truth and a historical fact. It is another matter that you are so upset with the declining fortunes of your party that you cannot accept truths and facts.
Then there is the Congress which is trying to score a few brownie points. Congress leader Rajiv Shukla, in his capacity as a member of the Board for Control of Cricket in India, said that the Shiv Sena chief was talking like Mohammad Ali Jinnah. Meanwhile, his party has ensured that no action is taken against the outrage in the Maharashtra Assembly. He has also given fodder for another meaningless debate: are Bal Thackeray and Jinnah similar?
There is an urgent need to change the climate of opinion; the way public discourse is currently carried out is an affront to reason and decency.
And what kind of climate of opinion we are condemned to suffer? It could not get more polluted. It is indeed a testimony of the rottenness of public debate that the indubitable criminality of Raj Thackeray and his MNS has been bestowed a semblance of respectability. A few things are manifestly true. The MNS legislators assaulted Samajwadi Party legislator Abu Azmi inside the Maharashtra Assembly because he insisted on taking oath in Hindi. They were ordered or instigated to do so by Raj. The MNS chief had said before the oath-taking ceremony, “If any MLA does not take oath in Marathi, the House will see what happens.”
The offenders have not denied the assault; at any rate, there is television footage which has recorded the outrage. Yet, nothing substantial has been done to punish the wrong-doers; they have been barred from the Assembly for four years, but this is not commensurate with the offence, which is much graver. Further, an unnecessary language debate has begun, engendering meaningless questions and issues. Is it wrong to take oath in the nation language, Hindi? Should a legislator speak only the language of his state? Did Azmi intend to demean Marathi? The chatter is endless; and this endlessness ends up fading the felony: that is, physical violence against a legislator on the floor of the House.
Worse, politicians of other parties have jumped in the fray—not to establish the rule of law but to make political capital. Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray had the brazenness to castigate cricket icon Sachin Tendulkar for the latter’s comment: “Mumbai belongs to India. That is how I look at it. And I am a Maharashtrian and I am extremely proud of that but I am an Indian first.” Bal Thackeray wrote in the Sena mouthpiece Saamna, “There was no need for him to take a cheeky single by making such remarks.” Well, Mr Thackeray, Tendulkar does not need any cheeky singles; he has done pretty well both on the ground and off it to score a brownie point. He did not make any political statement; he stated a geographical truth and a historical fact. It is another matter that you are so upset with the declining fortunes of your party that you cannot accept truths and facts.
Then there is the Congress which is trying to score a few brownie points. Congress leader Rajiv Shukla, in his capacity as a member of the Board for Control of Cricket in India, said that the Shiv Sena chief was talking like Mohammad Ali Jinnah. Meanwhile, his party has ensured that no action is taken against the outrage in the Maharashtra Assembly. He has also given fodder for another meaningless debate: are Bal Thackeray and Jinnah similar?
There is an urgent need to change the climate of opinion; the way public discourse is currently carried out is an affront to reason and decency.
Friday, November 13, 2009
Clichés as foreign policy
Do we have a foreign policy? A look at the events all over the world makes it difficult to answer in the affirmative, for pusillanimity, stodginess, and gross ineptitude have become the hallmark of Indian diplomacy.
While the geopolitical situation is increasingly becoming hostile to our national interests, the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) Government is responding with a timorousness which borders on idiocy. A day after China screamed about the Dalai Lama’s visit to Arunachal Pradesh, the authorities asked him to amend his programme; the reporters covering his trip were asked to leave Tawang. Did anyone in Arunachal have any problems with the Dalai? No, they gave him a hearty welcome. Did anybody—that is anybody other than the known Beijing lackeys—in other parts of the country have any problems with his visit? No. But the mandarins in the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) get jittery every time China screams. And, obviously, they lack the courage to have hard talk with Beijing, which has been fomenting trouble in the North-East and supplying arms to Pakistan, our mortal enemy and a terrorist state.
The latest instance of Beijing’s villainy is its decision to sell Pakistan 36 fighter aircraft for a consideration of $1.4 billion. And now another revelation has come: China provided Pakistan with a “do-it-yourself” kit and weapons grade uranium for making two nuclear bombs in 1982. According to The Washington Post, the deliberate act of proliferation was part of a secret nuclear deal struck in 1976 between Chinese leader Mao Zedong and Pakistan’s prime minister Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto.
“Upon my personal request, the Chinese Minister... had gifted us 50 kg [kilograms] of weapon-grade enriched uranium, enough for two weapons,” the notorious nuclear smuggler, AQ Khan wrote in a previously undisclosed 11-page narrative of the Pakistani bomb programme. But the MEA is still determined to placate Beijing.
Similarly, the MEA has miserably failed to influence US policy, which is increasingly becoming more pro-Islamabad, the epitome of which is the Barack Obama Administration’s decision to appoint Robin Raphel as coordinator for non-military aid to Pakistan
It is a well-known fact that Raphel is a rabid and despicable India-hater. She is notorious for her sympathies with Pakistan who, as Assistant Secretary of State for South Asia, said in 1994 that Kashmir was “disputed territory”; she questioned the legitimacy of the Instrument of Accession. Obama’s decision to proffer a high office mocks at his stated antipathy towards keeping lobbyists in Washington’s power structure, for a lobbying firm recently made a disclosure that she worked earlier with it. But so committed is Obama to the cause of Pakistan that he had little compunctions in violating his own Administration’s code of ethics regarding appointments.
Raphel is already part of the Administration, having joined it in August, her entry being facilitated by Richard Holbrooke, US Special Envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan. Before her appointment by the US President, she worked with the lobbying firm, Cassidy and Associates. The firms had a $1.2-million contract with Pakistan. Obama has turned a blind eye to such blatant conflict of interests. The question is: what has the UPA regime been doing all along? While the political leadership’s failure is spectacular in matters related to diplomacy, our Indian Foreign Service officers have not covered themselves with glory. It is quite evident that they, like our politicians, are apt only at making hackneyed remarks and meaningless statements.
While the geopolitical situation is increasingly becoming hostile to our national interests, the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) Government is responding with a timorousness which borders on idiocy. A day after China screamed about the Dalai Lama’s visit to Arunachal Pradesh, the authorities asked him to amend his programme; the reporters covering his trip were asked to leave Tawang. Did anyone in Arunachal have any problems with the Dalai? No, they gave him a hearty welcome. Did anybody—that is anybody other than the known Beijing lackeys—in other parts of the country have any problems with his visit? No. But the mandarins in the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) get jittery every time China screams. And, obviously, they lack the courage to have hard talk with Beijing, which has been fomenting trouble in the North-East and supplying arms to Pakistan, our mortal enemy and a terrorist state.
The latest instance of Beijing’s villainy is its decision to sell Pakistan 36 fighter aircraft for a consideration of $1.4 billion. And now another revelation has come: China provided Pakistan with a “do-it-yourself” kit and weapons grade uranium for making two nuclear bombs in 1982. According to The Washington Post, the deliberate act of proliferation was part of a secret nuclear deal struck in 1976 between Chinese leader Mao Zedong and Pakistan’s prime minister Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto.
“Upon my personal request, the Chinese Minister... had gifted us 50 kg [kilograms] of weapon-grade enriched uranium, enough for two weapons,” the notorious nuclear smuggler, AQ Khan wrote in a previously undisclosed 11-page narrative of the Pakistani bomb programme. But the MEA is still determined to placate Beijing.
Similarly, the MEA has miserably failed to influence US policy, which is increasingly becoming more pro-Islamabad, the epitome of which is the Barack Obama Administration’s decision to appoint Robin Raphel as coordinator for non-military aid to Pakistan
It is a well-known fact that Raphel is a rabid and despicable India-hater. She is notorious for her sympathies with Pakistan who, as Assistant Secretary of State for South Asia, said in 1994 that Kashmir was “disputed territory”; she questioned the legitimacy of the Instrument of Accession. Obama’s decision to proffer a high office mocks at his stated antipathy towards keeping lobbyists in Washington’s power structure, for a lobbying firm recently made a disclosure that she worked earlier with it. But so committed is Obama to the cause of Pakistan that he had little compunctions in violating his own Administration’s code of ethics regarding appointments.
Raphel is already part of the Administration, having joined it in August, her entry being facilitated by Richard Holbrooke, US Special Envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan. Before her appointment by the US President, she worked with the lobbying firm, Cassidy and Associates. The firms had a $1.2-million contract with Pakistan. Obama has turned a blind eye to such blatant conflict of interests. The question is: what has the UPA regime been doing all along? While the political leadership’s failure is spectacular in matters related to diplomacy, our Indian Foreign Service officers have not covered themselves with glory. It is quite evident that they, like our politicians, are apt only at making hackneyed remarks and meaningless statements.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)