Friday, October 21, 2011

Muslim clerics slam jihadi ideology

It is a sad commentary on the conformism of our times that Muslim clerics, and not our voluble secular liberals, have taken on Wahhabism, the most virulent form of Islam. Maulana Syed Mohammad Ashraf Kachochavi, general secretary of the All-India Ulama & Mashaikh Board (AIUMB), a Sufi sect, recently said at a public meeting in Moradabad, “Hamey Wahhabiyon ka na Immamat kabool hai, na kayadat Kabul (We reject the religious and political leadership of Wahabis).”
He thundered, “If anyone knocks on your door with the message of extremism, hand him over to the nearest police station.” He hit the nail on its head, for Wahhabism wants to freeze time in the seventh century, at least for the Muslims all over the world. It was propounded by a theologian, Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab (1703–1792), from Najd in what is now Saudi Arabia. The movement strives to purge Islam of all impurities and innovations.
Wahhabism is the official version of Islam in Saudi Arabia. It is the ideology that inspires al-Qaeda, the Taliban, and the countless other terrorist organizations.
Wahhabism got a big fillip when petroleum exports made the Arabian Peninsula and other Muslim countries rich. Saudi petrodollars in particular financed a number of schools, seminaries, and mosques as well as social programmes in the entire world. Thanks to the inveterate misogyny and limitless intolerance of Wahhabism, the consequences were catastrophic for Muslim women, pluralism, and liberalism in the Islamic world and elsewhere.
Kachochavi was right when he said, “About 100 years ago, Sunni Muslims in India had rejected the Wahabis. After Independence, however, the Wahhabis expanded their influence through political backing. While we remained away from government and politics, Wahhabis gained control over institutions dealing with minority affairs, including the wakf board and the Muslim Personal Law Board.”
AIUMB spokesperson Syed Babar Ashraf pointed out that while four out of five Indian Muslims believe in the Sunni Sufi tradition, the Wahhabis have control over just 13-14 per cent of the community. “But a large section of the Urdu press has boycotted us. They are controlled by hardliners.”
Terming the outfits like Deoband, Jamiat Ulama-e-Hind, and Ahl-e-Hadees as Wahhabi-inspired bodies, he said, “They are funded by petro-dollars and aim to grab political power.”
The Sufi conclave got the full support of Islamic scholar Sultan Shahin: “It is for the first time that mainstream Ulema have come out so strongly against Wahabism which is slowly but determinedly spreading in this country.” According to him, “Islam spread in India through the Sufi saints. But all that changed with the infusion of Saudi petrodollars. For me the most worrying example is Pakistan. Everything that happened there a decade ago is happening here today.”
Faizur Rahman, secretary-general of the Forum for the Promotion of Moderate Thought Among Muslims, also reacted in a similar fashion. “There are books of fatwas written by Saudi clerics which contain such abhorrent ruling as those that declare a Muslim who does not pray five times to be a ‘kafir’ and say that he must be killed and ‘buried outside the graveyards of the Muslims’ if he does not repent.”
But the most retrograde sections among the Muslim community were rattled by the statements made by the AIUMP leaders. Darul Uloom rector Maulana Qasim Nomani lashed out at both the AIUMB and the English press for giving good coverage to the Sufi event. “Why did the English media front-page this news?” he asked.
Unsurprisingly, the Urdu press practically boycotted the Sufi event, but prominently displayed the reactions of Nomani. What is regrettable is that it is not only orthodox and narrow-minded people who have thrown their weight behind Wahhabism; even those who are expected to fight the fundamentalist ideology are actually supporting it. Consider the case of Mujtaba Khan, a professor at Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, a publicly funded institution. Its faculty is supposed to uphold such cherished principles of Indian Republic as freedom of religion, equality of women, and modernity. But what does Khan believe in?
According to him, “the contributions of Wahabi/Deobandi movements in extricating Muslim youth from many customs forbidden in Islam cannot be simply glossed over.” He is actually saying that the reaction against any sort of modernization is good; so, there is nothing wrong if acid is thrown on a Muslim woman who does not dress properly; it is also proper that those using religious freedom to go beyond the literal interpretation of Koran are treated shabbily; it is also in the fitness of things that homosexuals, apostates, etc., are killed.
Intellectuals like Khan try to downplay or overlook the bigotry of such Wahhabi-inspired organizations. A recent instance of their bigotry was the demand by Darul Uloom Deoband for a ban on the followers of Ahmadiya sect to perform Haj. In a letter to the King of Saudi Arabia, the seminary urged him to act against the Ahmadiyas, also known as Qadianis.
It is not just Muslim luminaries like Khan but almost the entire intellectual class of India that refuse to see the evil of Wahhabism and the resultant Islamic terror. They are loath to take on the jihadis for the fear of being dubbed as ‘communal’ or fanatical. So, ironically, now Muslim clerics are fighting the jihadi ideology.

Monday, October 17, 2011

Hypocrisy unlimited

Why is there a gulf between public discourse and private deliberations? Anything that is asserted, cherished, and promoted in the public domain is almost always at variance with what is appreciated, esteemed, and encouraged in private life.
Let’s begin with one of the most important things in the world—money. All of us—at any rate, all of us, save the fortunate few—work for money. Most people spend almost three-fourths of the time, effort, and energy on earning money, investing it prudently, or spending it cautiously. In its pursuit, men and women perform heroic, even superhuman feats; they also commit the most heinous crimes. Money consumes us; it makes and breaks relationships. It shapes our viewpoint, attitude, and values. It plays an extremely important role in our life. It is the axis around which the world revolves. It molds our relationships. Unsurprisingly, we remember our rich uncles and forget poor cousins.
Yet, its importance is routinely downplayed. Religions put scorn on money and the moneyed; moralizers warn us about the dangers of mammon worship; movies tell us that the rich are bad and the poor are good (and the poor vanquish the rich); intellectuals often equate money with theft (and do their best to replenish their own coffers).
One word that describes mankind’s duplicity is hypocrisy. Perhaps, America is the only country in the world where wealth is generally seen as a reward for enterprise and endeavor, though there is no dearth of moralizers railing against money even there. America’s success in bridging the gap between public discourse and private deliberations has a great deal to do with its economic might, political clout, technological prowess, and military muscle.
India’s relationship with America has been unique. In an article (November 29, 2009, The Economic Times), Swaminathan Aiyar wrote, “During the Cold War, India's governmental relations were warm with the USSR and cool with the US. But a million Indians migrated to the US while none went to the USSR.” The question is: why? India is a democracy, so its political class is supposed to reflect the views, feelings, and aspirations of the people. But why was it that while the people of India felt, and feel, at home in Washington, New York, and other U.S. cities (and in the West in general), our leaders found friends in Moscow and Jakarta? India and the U.S. have had strong economic ties (the U.S. is the biggest trade partner), social and cultural relations, but the political ties have often lacked warmth; at times, there was pronounced hostility between the world’s two biggest democracies.
The answer lies in socialism, the ideology that delineated our economic and foreign policies during much of the second half of the twentieth century. It can be called the most overrated ideology the world has ever witnessed; all over the world, intellectuals generally favor it as much as common people detest it.
Socialism means controls which lead to shortages; anybody who has lived in pre-liberalization India knows it very well because they have suffered it. Socialism means licences, even for radio and television. It means that even if you build your own house with your own hard-earned money, you have to run from pillar to post for cement. It means that when you have a marriage in your family, you have to go to a babu with the invitation card for the release of sugar. It means that you have to wait for years to buy a scooter. It means that essential amenities like gas cylinder and telephone connection, you have either to wait indefinitely or seek favor from a politician or a ‘well-connected’ person. It means that for good things in life, you look askance at imported stuff. Yet, intellectuals love socialism. And, despite the failure of socialism all over world, they preach its virtues.
But thanks to our intellectuals love for socialism, the public discourse in India is generally against multinational corporations (MNCs) and big industry. Our intellectuals never tire railing against big companies. We are told that these companies exploit their employees, bribe politicians and bureaucrats, break or mold rules and regulations, evade taxes, and don’t care a hoot about the environment. Yet, if you ask any non-intellectual if they would like to work with a big company—or if they want their children to be employed by an MNC—the answer would be a big ‘yes’ (Most intellectuals also would reply in a similar fashion in private, but that is another story). Common people know that big companies pay well, have a better working atmosphere, and are not run by the whims and fancies of small, proprietary firms—at least, at the lower and middle levels. They are happy working with big companies.
But intellectuals claim that they are exploited by corporate tycoons. Oxford Dictionary defines the verb ‘exploit’ as ‘make use of (a situation) in a way considered unfair or underhand’ or ‘benefit unfairly from the work of (someone).’ In the normal sense of the term, MNC employees are not exploited; this is the reason they work or aspire to work for MNCs and big companies. Intellectuals, however, have nothing to do with the normal or the obvious; they are comfortable with the dogma Karl Marx propounded over a century-and-a-half ago, called the Theory of Surplus Value. No amount of empirical evidence can shake their faith in the discredited Theory. People like MNCs, but these remain ugly in public discourse.
Similarly, most people want to earn their own living. They also want their children to be self-dependent. In all societies, the virtues of endeavor and diligence are cherished. But public discourse in our country is all about shaping the political economy in such a way that more and more people become dependent on state largesse. It a family member or friend suffers huge financial losses or is ruined, we try to help him by increasing his earning rather than paying him regular donations. Lead a man to fish, they say, feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, feed him for life. Not that there is no altruism. We make sacrifices and take pains to help our buddies, family members, etc. But the idea is to help who needs it rather than make them dependent on us.
But when it comes to public discourse and political debate, everything turns topsy-turvy. Poverty alleviation grabs the attention of policy-makers, politicians, and bureaucrats—which is fine. However, the means employed are the ones opposite to those which we would never employ in our personal capacity. They conceive publicly-funded schemes, establishing postmodern feudalism, with government as a gigantic lord and the poor as permanent dependants. The lord gives and the serf receives, making the latter to perennially look askance at the former. The entitlement mindset is promoted. Personally, we don’t like our dear ones to be our dependants; politically, we do it all the time. With great aplomb, as if the creation of serfdom were a remarkable feat.
Consider another public-private dichotomy. Politicians of various hues claim to be the champions of vernaculars. They aggressively campaign to change the names of cities to make these echo the local dialect. Bombay becomes Mumbai; Madras, Chennai; Calcutta, Kolkata; Bangalore, Bengaluru. In the name of promoting Indian languages, they bar English from government schools in the primary classes, thus ensuring that the children with humble origins—for it is normally they who attend such schools—are handicapped for life in their career pursuits. It is a well-known fact that English enables a person to get a better job, move faster in any profession, and get better connected with the world. Politicians themselves acknowledge this fact and, therefore, send their own kids to English-medium schools; they also send their children to the U.K. and the U.S. for higher education. What is good in private becomes bad in the public domain and political arena.
Similarly, villages and rural life are glorified and valorized in public discourse. Politicians and intellectuals go lyrical in describing the ethos and pathos of country life; but all of them live in cities, and will continue to live in cities. And their children will also live in cities.
There are many other instances which illustrate the gulf between private beliefs and public posturing. Can this gulf ever be abridged? Not until the intellectual and moral bankruptcy of our opinion makers is exposed.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Rahul gives 99 per cent marks to Govt

It requires inveterate superciliousness for a person to make preposterous and insensitive comments on a regular basis. Rahul Gandhi is one such person. This gets confirmed, if confirmation was required, from his 99 per cent remark about the Bombay serial blasts on July 13.
The terror attack killed 17 and wounded many more, rattled the commercial capital of the country, and angered all Indians. A day after the outrage, as the city was trying to limp back to normal and the victims were groaning in hospitals, the crown prince said that total elimination of terror attacks was impossible. He went on to laud his own government for having largely succeeded in controlling terror assaults.
“It’s very difficult to stop every single terror attack. Terrorism is impossible to stop all the time. But 99 per cent of terror attacks have been stopped due to strong vigilance and intelligence efforts,” he said.
So, what should we do? Instead of castigating the Congress-led governments in New Delhi and Bombay for their gross incompetence and worse in checking the jihadis, should we hail Rahul, the lame duck Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, and the super-Prime Minister, Sonia mama as divine creatures? Should we sing hosannas in praise of such gods and goddesses? By making such gauche remarks, Rahul has added salt to the injuries of the victims.
Then there is Home Minister P. Chidambaram who reacts by saying that all cities are vulnerable to attacks. He went on to say that terrorism is a global phenomenon. At a press conference, he listed the number of attacks in other countries. So, we have some consolation: it is not only the Indians but others as well who are dying because of terror! Thank God for small mercies.
Of late, the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government has begun peddling a perverse form of globalization. When questions are asked about soaring inflation, they say it’s happening all over the world. When it faces flak for its ineptitude in tackling jihad, it says terrorism is not restricted to India.
While it is true that global commodity prices have been hardening for some time, it is undeniable that mindless populism of the government has also augmented the aam aadmi’s torment. Similarly, developments in Pakistan and Afghanistan and regular terror funding from the Middle East are a big problem, but the sins of omission and commission by the UPA regime are too obvious to be ignored. But Rahul, who represents Amethi in the Lok Sabha, said, “We have improved by leaps and bounds.”
Evidently, what Rahul, Chidambaram, and other Congress leaders are saying is a lot of baloney. Yes, terror strikes have been happening all over the world, but no such thing has happened in the US since the September 11 attacks in 2001. Similarly, the UK was able to stop any incident after the London terror attack on July 7, 2005.
At the heart of the terror problem in our country is the propensity of the Congress, and other political parties, to mollycoddle Muslims fundamentalists and incorrigible fanatics. Congress leaders such as Digvijay Singh—who, by the way, is Rahul’s mentor—have always opposed policies and actions that can have a deterrent effect on jihadis. The aftermath of Batla House encounter is testimony to their brazen appeasement of Muslim hardliners.
Rahul’s superciliousness and insensitivity are the product and function of this appeasement.

Food security law wil spell doom

A short but extremely significant statement that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh made during his interaction with newspaper editors went largely unnoticed. About the proposed Food Security Bill, he said, “Maximum that has been procured is 57 million [tones of food grain]; the average procurement for the last couple of years is 55 million tones. We have to work out a system within this.”
This is an unambiguous refutation of the obstinate position taken by the Sonia Gandhi-led National Advisory Council (NAC). The NAC wants to give legal entitlement to highly subsidized food grain to 70 per cent of the population. This translates into about 80 million people getting with monthly ration of 7 kg for every member of families below the poverty line and 3 kg to each individual from “general households.”
As is its wont, the Leftist-infested NAC is trying to expand the role and scope of government in food grain distribution, while Singh is trying to limit the populism to whatever extent it can. Earlier, it looked like the Prime Minister was fighting a losing battle, for his own ministers are seem keener to follow the NAC chief’s diktats than to obey his commands. Food minister K.V. Thomas, for instance, told The Economic Times in an interview (May 30), “[The Food Security Bill] has been drafted under the direction of Madam Sonia Gandhi.”
The Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Committee (PMEAC), headed by former Reserve Bank governor C. Rangarajan, has serious differences with the NAC on a variety of issues. But it must be noted that the PMEAC’s resistance to the NAC’s big state measures is feeble and based on practical considerations. While the NAC wants is indulges in demagoguery to increase the number of beneficiaries of subsidized food-grain, the PMEAC meekly favors such subsidies for 46 per cent of rural population and 28 per cent of the urban people.
So, nobody is talking about, let along opposing, the moral hazard of Leviathan statism; there is no ideological or principled opposition to the giant strides being made in government spending. This is despite the fact that, in absolute numbers, the fiscal deficit stands at Rs 3.69 lakh crore, which is much higher than Rs 139,231 crore in 2004-05, when the Manmohan Singh government took charge.
The NAC jihadis, of course, have no regard for the concept of fiscal prudence. Like spoilt brats who, unbothered about the family income, always pester their parents with ever-rising demands, they incessantly work on schemes that would be ruinous for the exchequer.
Apart from the strain on public finance, there is the ethical issue of creating and nurturing an entitlement mindset among vast sections of society. They would be eternally looking for succor from the state.
And since pilferage and graft are the inevitable consequences of state expenditure, one can safely assume huge rise in the spread and scale of corruption in the public distribution system.
Instead of looking for novel ideas for improving food-grain distribution and increasing the role of private sector for efficiency, the government remains stuck with linear thinking. Among other things, it is trying to transform the inherently inefficient Food Corporation of India (FCI) into a modern, competent machine to address the gigantic task of grain distribution. As Thomas said, “Compared to earlier periods, the recruitment in Food Corporation of India has risen by 10 per cent. We have modernized FCI go-downs through computerization. Sitting in my office, I know the quantity, quality and distribution of grain from each go-down. We have put CCTV cameras to watch operations. We have also enabled e-transactions; every payment above 1 lakh will be e-transacted. To complement all this, PDS will be improved through Aadhar.”
In short, the idea is cure socialism with more socialism. The endeavor is doomed, for the capabilities of FCI are grossly inadequate. A recent study conducted by, among others, chairman of the Commission for Agricultural Costs and Prices (CACP) Ashok Gulati said that FCI’s efficiency was half that of private traders.
Further, the proposed food security legislation can be pervasive enough to drive out private companies. The study also recommended that the government, instead of embarking on a massive exercise in food-grain distribution, should explore the options of cash transfers and food coupons.
“Strangulating the private sector could impact other key areas in agriculture, including seed and storage where its role would become even more crucial now,” the study said. Ad hoc government policies have already adversely affected the private sector in a few states.
The Left-leaning activists of the NAC are not satisfied by higher government expenditure and the attack on the private sector; they want more; the council reportedly wants complete ban on food grain exports.
More radical Leftists are dissatisfied by even the NAC’s recommendations. Jean Dreze, who is credited with conceiving the rural employment guarantee scheme, is not comfortable with the existing NAC proposals. Appeasement of the Left is a Sisyphean task.

From Cyberia to Siberia

The recent government effort to police blogs is yet another assault on the freedom of expression. It emanates from the belief among our political masters that the lesser mortals need to be constantly monitored and, if need arises, reprimanded for infractions. And, of course, only our betters can define what constitutes an infraction.
The draft rules, derived from the Information Technology Amendment Act, 2008, describe the due diligence an intermediary is expected to carry out. An “intermediary” is an entity that?on behalf of another?receives, stores, or transmits any electronic record. So, intermediaries include telecom networks, web-hosting and Internet service providers, search engines, online payment and auction sites, cyber cafes, and even bloggers.
The proposed rules stipulate that hosts or owners of websites must take action against “objectionable content” that is considered “disparaging,” “harassing,” “blasphemous,” or “hateful.” They are ordered to act against anything that “threatens the unity, integrity, defence, security or sovereignty of India, friendly relations with foreign countries, or public order.”
Such verbosity, however, does not fool everybody about the nefarious designs of our political masters. As Nikhil Pahwa, editor and publisher of the news and analysis website, MediaNama, was quoted in The Hindu (May 11, 2011): “These rules give the Indian government the ability to gag free speech, and block any website it deems fit, without publicly disclosing why sites have been blocked, who took the decision to block it, and, just as importantly, providing adequate recourse to blogs, sites and online and mobile businesses, for getting the block removed.”
Three points need to be made in this regard. First, there is absolutely no need to bring in any rules to monitor or regulate blogs and other modes of communication on the Net. Such communications, unfettered by governmental or other controls, offer a platform to common citizens to express their views about anything under the sun.
It is true that often the postings by Indian bloggers and others are not the best examples of elegant prose, poise, and sobriety; apart from bad English, there are vituperation, racial abuse, etc. But even the most abusive of Internet communications have not caused any law and order problem. Nor has there been any demand from any section—not even from any tetchy group. So, why is there an attempt to impose censorship in the first place?
Second, if the government decides to regulate cyberia, it will call for a huge drain on the public exchequer. For the task would truly gargantuan—countless blogs, the sites of all newspapers, magazines, news channels, innumerable portals, etc. Then there are websites of foreign media houses and organizations. Who would regulate them? The proposed rules would be practically unimplementable.
When laws are unimplementable, they weaken the individual, strengthen the state, and promote discretion in the affairs of state. The most likely consequence: officers of the state would use the ban on breathing at will—for rent-seeking or repression.
And, finally, there is the issue of burden on our law-enforcement apparatus. Have our cops solved all cases? Have our courts disposed of the millions of cases that have been waiting for years?
The proposed rules are a gauche attempt by meddlesome mandarins to control the Net. It is perhaps the first time that the Indian government has embarked on such a venture in India, though Internet censorship is rampant in repressive regimes like China, Iran, Cuba, Saudi Arabia, and North Korea.
Unfortunately, freedom of expression is facing relentless assaults not just from the state. An assortment of forces—the Left and the Right, the pre-modern mullahs and postmodern intellectuals, publicity hungry outfits and rabid busybodies—is busy in activities that end up shrinking the sphere of individual liberty (and, concomitantly, augmenting the scope and role of Indian state). It is a veritable Inquisition. Unlike the original Inquisition—which was an ecclesiastical tribunal or institution of the Roman Catholic Church for combating or suppressing heresy—the contemporary enemies of individual liberty and open society are a multifarious lot who want to proscribe anything and everything that can “hurt the sentiments” of any community, creed, or group. It is like a rainbow coalition against individual liberty. They inveigh against books, movies, songs, etc; often the protest becomes violent.
With a frightening frequency, demands are made for ban of this or that book, movie, song, etc, because it “hurt the sentiments” of some persons, groups, or communities. This is despite the fact that ‘sentiments’ are arbitrary and subjective. Some Hindus’s sentiments may get hurt by M.F. Husain’s Saraswati painting, while others are not offended. Similarly, Taslima Nasreen’s novels may or may not hurt the sentiments of the Muslims. The predominantly Christian West was not offended by The Da Vinci Code movie, while many Indian Christians were.
The social and cultural backdrop adds an alarming dimension to the government effort to control the Net. A draconian fiat may see the light of the day without much protest.

Saturday, June 18, 2011

Maligning BJP: An illiberal strategy

Congress general secretary Digvijay Singh’s intemperate remarks against Baba Ramdev and the incessant attempts to link the yoga guru to the Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) should be seen as part of the grand old party’s strategy to keep itself in power in perpetuity. The idea is not only to malign Ramdev but also to present the Sangh Parivar as demonic and anything connected with it taboo. It is a strategy to keep the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) aloof from other parties.
The reasons are not difficult to find. The Manmohan Singh Government, remote-controlled by Congress president Sonia Gandhi, has comprehensively failed on all fronts: inflation is killing the aam aadmi for whom the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) so sanctimoniously professes to work; corruption is rampant; industry is exasperated with rent-seeking; the economy has started feeling the strains of the UPA regime’s mindless populism; national security is in a mess, thanks to the Congress’ desire to win brownie points among Muslim fundamentalists; and foreign policy is in a shambles, the recent blunder being indirect support to the tyrant Gaddafi by opposing Nato strikes in Libya. The only way the ruling coalition can sustain for a substantial period of time is by keeping the Opposition divided.
The BJP got 18.8 per cent vote in the 2009 general elections, down from 22.16 per cent vote in 2004; for the Congress, the corresponding figures were 28.55 per cent and 26.53 per cent. Any genuine non-Congress formation at the Centre is inconceivable without the BJP.
It is not for the first time that Digvijay Singh has chosen to castigate the Sangh Parivar. On December 19 last year, he said, as reported by PTI, “In the 1930s, Hitler’s Nazi party attacked the Jews... Similarly, the RSS ideology wants to capture power by targeting Muslims under the garb of furthering nationalism.” Further, he said, “Demolition of the Babri Masjid... is the darkest patch in the history of India. The roots of terrorism in India lie in BJP leader L.K. Advani’s rath yatra.”
He would like us believe that Lashkar-e-Taiyaba, ISI, etc., are not at the root of terror. However, his own party colleagues in the Government are unlikely to agree with him, but that is another story. What is germane to this article is the fact that Congress leaders like Digvijay Singh, and the intellectuals sympathetic to his party, have always tried to smear BJP (and earlier, the Bharatiya Jana Sangh) so that it could be left apart from the mainstream.
A fear psychosis is conjured up about ‘communalism’; and, concomitantly, ‘secularism’ is presented as the shield against all the evils that ‘communal forces’ could spawn. The propaganda is so vicious and misleading that the two words, ‘communal’ and ‘secular’ have been divested of their original meanings. A Briton or an American unfamiliar with the conditions in India may find the connotations of the two words bewildering. Congress leaders and their lackeys in the opinion-making apparatus have not only vitiated politics but also ravaged the English language. In their make-believe world, a big part of the Indian political system, the BJP, is dubbed as forbidden; any association with it is portrayed as vile.
More than the Congress leaders, it is the intellectuals who have played a key role in perpetuating the GOP’s misrule in the country. Careers have been made and fortunes built by lambasting the BJP.
Not that the project has succeeded completely. The first time that the Congress got an electoral setback was in 1967; the SVD governments were formed in states. Interestingly, it was the socialist leader Ram Manohar Lohia who chalked out the strategy of anti-Congressism and joined hands with the BJS.
In 1977, another socialist leader, Jayaprakash Narayan, also decided to include the saffron forces into the grand alliance against Indira Gandhi’s Congress and the result was the first non-Congress regime in New Delhi after Independence. It was a diluted form of anti-Congressism in 1989, when the BJP and the Left supported the V.P. Singh government from outside, that Rajiv Gandhi was ousted from power, despite having secured a historic mandate five years earlier.
The Atal Bihari Vajpayee government (1998-2004) was also an exercise in anti-Congressism, the first time that a non-Congress government lasted full term. It included socialists like George Fernandes. Many of the constituents of the Vajpayee government are now part of the ruling United Progressive Alliance. In short, association with the saffron party did not cost them politically.
In this context, another point needs to be made. When we associate with somebody in politics or in life, we need not completely agree with them. If Anupam Kher supports Anna Hazare, it does not mean that the film actor will become a Gandhian like Hazare. In a liberal democracy, all of us are entitled to our viewpoints, so long as we don’t impose them on other by force. A natural corollary is that if we lampoon and criticize anybody just because they support the cause of our opponent, we only exhibit out intolerance. Our liberal commentators not only play into the hands of the Congress by joining the slam-BJP project but also show their own illiberal streak when they keep doing it blindly. Often, they end up becoming apologists for the monumentally corrupt and inept regimes like that of Manmohan Singh.

Cong, intellectuals try to fool people

A new doctrine has emerged since Anna Hazare sat on indefinite fast: the institutions of parliamentary democracy should be respected. There is nothing wrong with the assertion, but the doctrine is being abused to delegitimize a movement which so many people sympathize with.
It is true that many of the demands made by Hazare and then Baba Ramdev are impractical, that the tone and tenor of their discourse is excessively sentimental, that some statements made by their followers are outlandish, but this does not mean that the issue that the social activists are raising is inconsequential. It has been argued—quite convincingly, one may add—that there is no need for a Lokpal in the first place and that the corrupt can be thrown behind bars by properly utilizing the existing rules and apparatus. But the point is: who is interested in such action? The Congress-led regime in New Delhi is certainly not. This very fact makes the movement relevant and popular.
Fearful of the electoral consequences of the popular movement, the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government and its spin doctors have tried to belittle its importance and impact. Earlier, we were told that only the urban, English-speaking, middle class people are supporting Hazare and going to Jantar Mantar (As if these people belong to another world and have nothing to do with the country they live in. This is one of those Leftist theories that pollute the climate of opinion). But when Ramdev began his fast at Ramlila Maidan in Delhi and his followers turned out to be mostly from villages and suburban areas, it became evident that all sections of people—urban as well as rural, educated as well as not-very-educated, middle class as well as the poor—were supporting the movement.
Efforts were made to malign the Bhushans, ad hominem charges were hurled at those opposing the government. Finally, Ramdev was accused of being the front of the Sangh Parivar. What our liberal commentators did not explain was why an RSS front should be banished. After all, there are a number of Left-leaning outfits—many of which are front organizations of communist parties—which espouse various causes. For this very association, these outfits are not denounced. So, why should Right-leaning bodies and individuals be castigated for their ideological proclivities?
Congress leaders, Central ministers, pro-Congress intellectuals, and many other commentators tenaciously assert that the institutions of parliamentary democracy should be respected. None of these worthies, however, have pondered over a simple question: do the politicians of the day, including those who cite this doctrine, really believe in it?
It is an open secret that politicians of all parties have undermined these institutions; and the Congress has done the most harm because it has ruled the country for the maximum period of time. At any rate, democracy and individual liberty cannot be left to politicians alone, even if they are democratically elected. It was, after all, a democratically elected government that imposed the infamous Emergency in 1975 and gave the country a taste of authoritarian rule. And it was the Attorney General of that government, Niren De, who said in December 1975 in the Additional District Magistrate of Jabalpur versus Shiv Kant Shukla case, popularly known as the habeas corpus case, who said, “Even if life was taken away illegally, courts are helpless.”
It was the darkest chapter of our Supreme Court’s history that its bench decided against habeas corpus in April 1976. The majority decision was: “In view of the Presidential Order [declaring emergency] no person has any locus to move any writ petition under Article 226 before a High Court for habeas corpus or any other writ or order or direction to challenge the legality of an order of detention.”
It is to the eternal credit of Justice H.R. Khanna that he wrote a note of dissent, saying, “The Constitution and the laws of India do not permit life and liberty to be at the mercy of the absolute power of the Executive… What is at stake is the rule of law. The question is whether the law speaking through the authority of the court shall be absolutely silenced and rendered mute… Detention without trial is an anathema to all those who love personal liberty.”
A democratically elected government, under Indira Gandhi, had made Parliament a rubber stamp, subdued the press, repressed civil disobedience, trampled on democratic rights, and managed to convince the highest court of the land that the life of a citizen could be snuffed out by the state without any legal recourse. And it was an unelected man, Justice Khanna, who kept the flag of individual freedom flying!
Before Khanna, there was Mahatma Gandhi. He was also unelected. Obviously, electability is not and cannot be the necessary condition for being the voice of the people.
Our elected representatives have imposed many draconian laws and oppressive rules on us. Quite apart from such sinister moves, they weaken democratic institutions on a routine basis. They stall Parliament. Could there be anything more dangerous for democracy? Members of all parties regularly shout and try to silence their opponents on the floor of the House. They exceed the time limit the presiding officer of the House imposes on them; they frequently disobey the chair; Parliament is often reduced to a circus with members indulging in theatrics.
Besides, there is the issue of representativeness. How representative of us are our elected representatives? It is a well-known fact that factors like caste, community, monetary might, muscle power, and slavishness to party bosses often help people win elections. One has to ludicrously credulous to believe that all members of Parliament and state Assemblies represent us and Hazare, Ramdev, and their comrades don’t.
A ruling party genuinely concerned with the rise of graft would have engaged the activists as well as the Opposition in a meaningful manner, thus evolving a national consensus. It is unadulterated hubris on the part of the Congress which nudges it to the view that just by maligning social activists it would be able to fool all the people for all of the time.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Roy, Geelani are no freedom fighters

A clutch of terrorist and jihadi groups organize a seminar, ‘Azaadi — The Only Way’, in the heart of the national Capital. Many despicable characters, including Kashmiri separatist leader Syed Ali Shah Geelani, participate in the seminar. They air secessionist views and abuse all who stand for the nation.
Booker Prize winner Arundhati Roy, who has made it a point to befriend all scoundrel of India, said, “Kashmir has never been an integral part of India. It is an historical fact. Even the Indian Government has accepted this.” Of course, she skipped the minor details like when did the Indian Government accepted this “historical fact.” In her scheme of things, India became a “colonizing power” soon after its Independence.
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Arun Jaitley said, “The whole country was shocked when a large number of separatists groups met in Delhi under the nose of the Government and had a conference… Some misconceived representatives of civil society have advocated that these separatists were only advocating and exercising their free right to speech.”
Unfortunately, it is not only the “misconceived representatives of civil society” who are trying to pit freedom of speech against national security, as if India were ruled by some jingoistic tyrants who brook no dissent. Even the mainstream mediapersons, especially media Brahmins who love to pontificate, who are presenting it as a freedom of expression versus national security issue.
The fact is that Geelani and his buddies in the Kashmir Valley are hardcore jihadis who want to establish Shariat; they are the biggest enemies of all freedoms the modern world offers to mankind. Given a chance, they would transform the ‘paradise on earth’ into a Talibani hell, impose the most barbaric form of laws, and treat women like cattle.
Even without being in power, they have imposed partial Taliban rule in the Valley.
Besides, the Right to Freedom of Expression is meant for the citizens of India. Do Geelani, Row, and other traitors call themselves citizens of India?
Commenting on the controversy triggered off by the seminar and the demands for action against Geelani and Roy, Dileep Padgaonkar, who heads the three-member group of interlocutors for Kashmir, said “Our response should be that of a mature democracy. It should be based on cool reason and not the kind of emotional outbursts we witnessed yesterday.” Well, cool reason says that medieval morons should be dealt with firmly.
While Geelani-Roy attracted a lot of attention, the presence of Maoist sympathizers at the meeting was largely overlooked by the media. In this context, an August 2008 statement, made by Maoist spokesperson Azad who died in an encounter in July, is relevant: “The CC (central committee), CPI-Maoist, unequivocally supports Kashmiri people’s struggle for azadi and believes that one who does not support the people’s aspirations for freedom and independence can never be a democrat.”
It is not surprising that the Leftwing terrorists have a soft corner for the Kashmiri separatists—enemy’s enemy is a natural friend. The Azadi seminar presented the jihadis and the Maoists to form a deadly alliance. It also presented an opportunity to become a martyr to the cause of freedom. “Pity the nation that has to silence its writers for speaking their minds,” Roy said in her reaction to the reports that she and Geelani might be prosecuted.
The truth is that she and Geelani are no freedom fighters. The Azadi they cry about is a tirade against individual liberty and open society.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Aisha: Exhilarating

Aisha is that kind of movie which you would like to watch with your girlfriend/boyfriend, spouse, parents, friends, kids—with anybody. And at anytime—after getting a good increment or a yelling from the boss, in good mood or after a depressive phase. A blithe spirit pervades the movie, which is both exhilarating and elevating.
My only regret was that I had not read Jane Austen’s Emma on which it was based. Watching a good film made on a good novel is a great joy; I experienced this while watching Gone With The Wind and The Godfather.
Director Rajshree Ojha did an excellent job by telling a tale with great aplomb. It reminded me of the delightful romantic comedies that TCM often shows. I doubt if Sonam Kapoor would have won the accolades she has without the slick direction of Ojha. Sonam is perfectly suited for the role of a rich, somewhat spoilt, girl who overrates her own match-making skills. Ira Dubey, as a less glamorous and more caustic buddy, also does a good job.
Amrita Puri, the country lass who is a stranger in the cool and chic South Delhi, is simply charming. She fumbles and bumbles, calls polo “horse-waali hockey”; she is putty in the hands of the protagonist Aisha (Sonam), but finally rebels to the indiscretions of her new ‘maker.’ This was a high point of Sonam’s histrionic skills: she was brilliant in her portrayal of a rich girl whose belief in her skills has just been shattered; she genuinely appears nonplussed, baffled, and crestfallen.
Lisa Haydon looks gorgeous every inch. As a foreign-returned corporate executive, she appears quite authentic. The accent, the demeanor, the entire persona—everything about her is authentic and fascinating. This is a departure from the portrayal of NRIs in Hindi movies; usually, they are shown as vain, comical, or both. And she sings—well, not a Western number, some popular Hindi film song, or even a ghazal—but a traditional song. Not in Hindi, but in one of the dialects which I could not make out. The blend of the Westernized and the native was delectable; unfortunately, it did not last long.
Abhay Deol looked natural as a corporate executive. He was a typical Jane Austen hero—handsome, rich, intelligent, full of character. And brave; he doesn’t bat an eyelid before punching a heavily-muscled Dhruv (Arunoday Singh) for his dirty remark about Aisha. Singh tried to portray himself as a hunk as well as a Casanova; he does well, but it could have been better.
And then there is the inimitable Cyrus Sahukar; he is always a treat to watch. M.K. Raina, as Sonam’s father, looks exactly what he portrays: a rich businessman who dotes on her daughter despite her spendthrift ways, talks to her as a friend rather than an overbearing guardian, and surreptitiously eats halwa at night!
Much has been written, not without reason, about the brilliant production design, styling, costume designing, cinematography, etc. However, the theme of the movie has not been commented upon; it seems that the impressive gloss of craft mesmerized the reviewers who just overlooked the soul of the body of work.
Very subtly, as if believing in the adage that art lies in concealing art, Ojha tells the failure of a girl who tries to control the lives of others. Aisha is a well-meaning girl; her intentions are noble; she wants the people around her to be happy, and happily married. Only her understanding of happiness is flawed, or shallow as Arjun (Deol) tells her. Her concepts about many things, including happiness, do not exactly match with the objective reality. She thinks that the best thing for the Bahadurgarh girl would be to become a South Delhi snob; her problem is that she imposed her own concepts on the reality, and gets frustrated when the reality does not behave as per her concepts or diktats.
But she is a decent girl, willing to correct herself. And, happily, there is Arjun to help her—and help himself by taking their friendship to a greater level. He also rescues her from shallowness, the shallowness which prods our elites to take up fancy causes like animal welfare and mouth politically correct homilies.
In the end, of course, all major characters of the movie are happily married. Aisha matures and apparently reforms.
In real life, too, we have many kinds of people who want to impose their concepts on others. Some of them want women to dress ‘appropriately,’ lest they fall prey to the depredations of molesters. There are Muslim fundamentalists imposing burqa. Saffron fanatics tell youngsters not to celebrate Valentine’s Day. There are politicians and activists who want to ban smoking in movies and on television. And long goes the list of moral cops. These self-appointed guardians of society and nation want to impose their rigidities and idiocies on us. While Aisha is open to introspection and course-correction, the myriad big brothers believe that they are always right.
Normally, efforts to control people’s lives with prescription and proscription fail; in the process, however, many of us have to go through hell. For in India life is not a romantic comedy.

When icons become iconoclastic

What do the believers do when the idols of their temple start talking blasphemously? They are shocked, they become incredulous, even enter the state of denial. This was, at any rate, the fate of Saeed Naqvi when he interviewed Naseeruddin Shah (NewsX, July 20).
He could not believe when Naseer, an icon of parallel cinema, said that Shammi Kapoor, Dev Anand, and Dara Singh were his favorite actors in Hindi movies. Naqvi was so stunned that he actually asked the veteran actor whether it was a tongue-in-cheek remark; but Naseer made it clear that he was not joking. Naqvi, however, remained unconvinced till the end; in the winding-up remarks, he said that Naseer “is playing the fool with us.”
At the heart of Naqvi’s incredulity lies a generation’s weltanschauung. I am talking about the sixties’ generation which had swallowed and digested not only the economy and politics of socialism but also its esthetics. There was a big problem, though: the most popular art was dominated by the people who had little time for the True Theory, which was socialism. The Raj Kapoors, the Dev Anands, the Guru Dutts, the K. Asifs, the Dilip Kumars, the B.R. Chopras, the Prakash Mehras, and other movie moguls made movies to mint money or to create great art; they never bothered to do things as per the dogmas, doctrines, or straitjackets of the Theory. This greatly frustrated the pundits; so, they dubbed the mainstream as Commercial Cinema, a term that went to signify anything that was crude, crass, escapist, kitsch. This is commerce, not art, thundered the popes of esthetics.
Thanks to the entrenchment of socialism in the 1970s, the government took upon itself to redeem, among other things, cinema (the way it ‘redeemed’ the economy is well-known; the results were shortages, black market, arrested growth, and crony capitalism, but that is another story). The consequence of state intervention in the world of movies was Art Cinema. And pinkish pundits got the opportunity to chalk out its canons.
I have always found the term, Art Cinema, puzzling for two reasons. First, it is tautological: since cinema is a form of art, the coinage has some redundancy about it. Second, most of the movies that go with it are the antithesis of art. It is difficult to find anything beautiful, elevating, or sublimating in the dreariness and boredom peddled by the masters of Art Cinema. But these incongruities did not bother the sixties’ generation, which continued to patronize the ‘socially relevant’ movies.
Art Cinema flourished as long as the government funded it; and, in the same manner as an unviable public sector undertaking goes sick when the government stops financing it, the Art Cinema business got bust when the winds of liberalization hit the Indian shores in the 1990s. The Shyam Benegals and the Govind Nihalanis came to terms with the new reality and made films with mainstream stars. But, interestingly, the canons and myths of Art Cinema did not fade away with time; in fact, they have got entrenched in public discourse and common parlance.
It is not unusual to read a film review which tells us that this movie has a message (and is therefore is good movie) or that one does not have any message (and therefore is just entertaining). A movie, as per the accepted code of film critics, is good if it has a socially relevant message. A filmmaker ought to be a postman, apart from his mastery over the craft, to be a considered a good one. Such are the consequences of having a public discourse immersed in socialist-collectivist-tribalist ethic. Everything and everybody are good so long as they serve their utility to a collectivity.
It is a measure of not only the prevalence of collectivist ethic but also of shabby elitism and general mendacity that when any intellectual or a cinema person with intellectual pretensions is asked about their favorite film directors, they talk about Satyajit Ray, Mrinal Sen, Bimal Roy, Eisenstein, or some other high-sounding names. Many, if not most, of them relish Johny Mera Naam and Sholay, but they discuss only Pather Panchali.
I am yet to come across a person who has named, say, Vijay Anand and Raj Khosla. Naseer had the courage to call Dev Anand starrer Guide and Jewel Thief (both directed by Vijay Anand) as great movies. In fact, Naseer says that Guide is among the best movies ever made in the world.
Given this socio-cultural milieu, it was indeed courageous―brazen, some would say―on the part of Naseer to call Shammi Kapoor as his favorite actor, to say that he grew up on his movies. But it was not unnatural for a man who was born in 1950 to say that. As a teenager and as a young man, and as a person with deep interest in cinema, Naseer could not have avoided Kapoor or Dev Anand. In fact, the two are not just among the handsomest and most Westernized heroes but they also represented all that was stylish, elegant, graceful, and blithe in contemporary India. Quite obviously, the champions of social realism found little worth in the two stars of yesteryears.
Even if Naseer had called Raj Kapoor his favorite, it would have been grudgingly accepted, for Raj sold sugary socialism and sexy altruism for decades.
But Naseer is talking about Shammi, Dev sahib, and―horrors― Dara Singh in superlative terms! Worse, he has nothing good to say about Shyam Benegal; despite Naqvi’s prompting to call him as his favorite director, Naseer refused to do that; instead, he went on naming Shekhar Kapoor, Gulzar, and Sai Paranpai as his favorites. It will be very difficult to put the three in the Art Cinema camp. Paranjpai actually made delightful and thoroughly entertaining movies Chashm-e-baddur and Katha; she can scarcely be thrown in the company of those who portrayed the sordid, the morbid, and the unlovely on celluloid.
What blasphemy! Naseer has no regard for the high priests of Art Cinema and the votaries of Theory. No wonder, Naqvi, a sixties’ generation representative, was incredulous.

Heroism, fake and real

Naveen Jindal is a young parliamentarian and industrialist. At the age of 40, the Congress leader represents the Kurukshetra constituency of Haryana in the Lok Sabha for the second time. Scion of a leading business house, he looks after the rail, steel, and power businesses of the Jindal Group.
He has had his education at the best institutions—Hansraj College of the University of Delhi and the University of Texas. He lives in one of the best localities in New Delhi; his bungalow is worth Rs 137 crore or $31 million.
In the past, he successfully campaigned for the citizens’ right to carry the national flag, a feat that made him a media darling; he has often been portrayed as a young icon, a committed politician, an earnest leader.
In short, he has access to the best in the world, and he is exposed to a variety of influences—presumably, also, the influences of modernity, individual liberty, and the rule of law. And what does he do? He makes out a case for khaps, the caste councils in Haryana and adjoining areas which act as kangaroo courts and dispense with barbaric justice, including lynching!
Then there is Chandrapati, a countrywoman who was widowed 18 years ago and who lives in her soldier-husband’s home in Karora village, Haryana. The 56-year-old woman has two daughters and a son; she had one more son who worked as a mechanic, Manoj. He married a girl of the same gotra (lineage or clan), Babli. For this, his wife’s family murdered the couple in 2007 on the diktat of a local khap. For years Chandrapati fought heroically for justice, which resulted in the first-ever court conviction in an honor-killing case.
The unassuming peasant woman had to face apparently insurmountable problems. Society, the local administration, the countless departments devoted to the cause of welfare state, myriad ‘civil society’ bodies—nobody came to her rescue. She was alone in her crusade against injustice and medievalism. Between one and none, wrote Nietzsche, lies an infinity; but it can also be infinite courage. A nondescript countrywoman from a nondescript village showed just that.
She told an interviewer in The Times Of India (April 4), “First, there was the village boycott. Everyone watches us, nobody comes, nobody speaks to us. We have no relatives in this village either. There was a time when it was difficult to get rations and milk even. The hostility was tremendous. We can’t step out of home without the police. I had to run from pillar to post simply to file the FIR.
“Even after I filed a case against the murderers, the panchayat came to bargain. They wanted to pay us off and offered Rs 1 crore. They said they’d sell land if required. Then they said, ‘You have daughters, we’ll do things to them.’ So the pressure was always there. It’s been three years of living in fear. They can do anything, any time. We face it. We live through it. There is no choice. And it’s not over or anything. I will see this through to the Supreme Court, if it reaches that point.”
No two persons can be as different as Chandrapati and Jindal. While she had the courage and gumption to take on the mightiest, our young parliamentarian decided to make a covenant with the forces of medievalism and barbarity. “I just feel, because they [khaps] are part of my parliamentary constituency, I have told them, they wanted to come and meet me and they wanted me to take the views to the government, to which I said, ‘Yes, I am duty-bound, so I would listen to you and I would take your views to the government’,” Jindal said.
What, pray, are the views of khap leaders? They want ban on marriages between same gotra. Their argument is that tradition does not allow such marriages; the Government should respect the customs of the country; therefore, same-gotra marriages should be legally prohibited. The argument is backed with force—brutal force. And the warning to youngsters is simple: you had better comply, or else…
Khaps say that exceptions were made in the Hindu marriage law, allowing union where customs said so. If local customs were earlier taken into account, they should be done now as well.
The fact is that the existing provisions expand the sphere of individual liberty, by letting marriage between certain tradition-sanctioned relations. Khaps, on the other hand, are hell-bent on shrinking that sphere by limiting people’s choice. And Jindal is “duty-bound” to take their retrograde views to the quarters that matter! So much for the ‘vision’ of our ‘young icons.’
Another, and bigger, icon is Rahul Gandhi who, in the words of Prof. Ravinder Kaur, is “fascinated by caste arithmetic, perfecting the art with modern technology and databases.” Is it moral progress if a cannibal uses spoon and fork? And is it a crusade for liberty if apparently modern, Westernized, and suave politicians masquerade their power-lust and Mandalite means with PR varnish?

Taking stock of Mr. Singh

When Prime Minister Manmohan Singh started his second term a year ago, there was considerable optimism in the air: Voters had marginalized small parties with petty, parochial agendas; the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party was in disarray; and Mr. Singh’s Congress Party had a strong political mandate. Given Mr. Singh’s profession as an economist and his role in India’s 1991 big-bang economic reforms, hopes were high that he would continue the reform agenda.

A year later, the government has produced only marginal action. The long-awaited third-generation mobile-phone spectrum auctions finally took place; disinvestment in public-sector companies is on track; and the national highways program, which languished under Congress’s first-term government, has been revived. Mr. Singh, to his credit, has laid special emphasis on fixing the country’s terrible infrastructure.

But, regrettably, little has been done in the spirit of real liberalization—that is, to roll back state from economy and increase the influence of the private sector in the economy. For instance, the government is selling minority stakes in state-run companies to dress up fiscal figures, not actually privatizing them, as its predecessor BJP-led government did. Major industries, such as banking and energy, remain largely state-run.

Nothing has been done to eliminate the residual legacies of the pre-1991, socialist past. India’s labor laws are antiquated and need to be made more flexible so that companies can react to changing market conditions. During Mr. Singh’s first term in office, he could never have contemplated reform in this area because of his alliance with the Communist Party. Yet now he’s ditched that alliance and still hasn’t touched this important area of reform.

Nor has Mr. Singh strengthened property-rights protection, either in the physical or intellectual sense. Farmers, especially in tribal areas, still have little right to transfer land they occupy and till. Companies, both domestic and foreign, struggle to protect their intellectual property. In one recent example, the Supreme Court denied Novartis a patent on a major cancer drug on the grounds that it wasn’t a major “innovation.” The company is appealing the decision, but the message to foreign investors has already been sent.

If anything, the Congress Party-led government has worked against the spirit of economic reforms. The most prominent example of this is the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, created during Congress’s first term in office. The scheme guarantees the rural poor 100 days of work at the taxpayer’s expense. Apart from bleeding the public fisc to the tune of Rs 40,000 crore, the Act is creating conditions for permanent serfdom, with the Indian state as the feudal lord and millions as dependents. Congress has also expanded the state’s remit in education and is considering passing a Right to Food Act, which would further increase deficit.

Politics remains the major impediment to reform. Mr. Singh is unelected to his own parliamentary seat and has no political base of his own. The real power in the Congress is chairwoman Sonia Gandhi, who reigns as what the BJP policy makers like to call a kind of “super-prime minister.” She takes care of the political affairs of the party and the ruling coalition, while Mr. Singh takes care of the day-to-day running of government. Her most recent intervention was in favor of a caste-based census, a backward-looking suggestion that the BJP also supports.

India can’t afford this kind of left-leaning governance. The world’s most populous democracy is still a very poor country, with hundreds of thousands of people lacking even the most basic necessities. So long as New Delhi tries to solve all problems with the state, the slower growth will be—and the more people will be confined to poverty. A weak state also can’t confront the growing internal and external security threats the country faces; in particular, Maoist violence which has killed hundreds over the past year over vast swathes of the country.

Mr. Singh isn’t an economic neophyte; he understands what needs to be done. But will he stand up to Mrs. Gandhi and push reform? If he doesn’t, the drift will only continue and deepen.


This article was published in Wall Street Journal Asia on May 27, 2010

Friday, May 21, 2010

Unchecked in India: Political correctness takes giant strides

In Western countries Right-leaning authors, columnists, and commentators often bemoan the cantankerousness and absurdity of political correctness. This is not surprising because PC has become not only an abomination plaguing common parlance and free speech but also a device for the Left to promote its irrationalities and pathologies. In India, however, it is not just the Left but practically all political parties and social organizations that are ardently, and sometime violently, championing PC. At any rate, the casualty is always freedom of expression.
It is seldom that violent PC is successfully checked. In a recent such instance, the country’s Supreme Court came to the rescue of south Indian film actress Khusboo for her statement on pre-marital sex, virginity, and live-in relationships. In an interview in 2005, she had said it was not wrong for women to have pre-marital sex as long as they took precautions. Further, the Tamil actress said, it was “not fair of any educated youth to expect his wife to be a virgin.” She also found nothing objectionable in live-in relationships.
The reaction to her remarks was swift and severe. Many political parties and a few people from the film industry itself castigated her for, what they called, an attack on “Tamil culture and values.” The Dalit Panthers of India (DPI) and another political party, the Pattali Makkal Katchi (PMK), protested against her; the protest often degenerated into violence. But it was not the violent protestors and their instigators who were found on the wrong side of the law; Khushboo, on the other hand, faced more than 20 criminal suits filed against her! One reason was PMK was part of the ruling coalition in New Delhi, with its leader A. Ramadoss being the Health Minister at that time.
Hounded by the law as well as the lawless, Khushboo offered an open apology to Tamils, especially women, saying she would never even dream of sullying the image of the Tamil people. “Even in films, I never undertook roles that lowered the image of women,” she said in a statement. “I have the greatest regard for Tamils, especially Tamil women. If my remarks have hurt anybody’s feelings, I tender an apology. I am one among you and will always remain with you.” But her tormentors were unrelenting.
Her trials and tribulations are likely to end as the Supreme Court has made its sympathy for her quite evident. Its three-judge bench, headed by Chief Justice K.G. Balakrishnan, did not find anything wrong with live-in relationships, incorporating it in Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees the Right to Life with dignity, liberty, and respect.
The relief for Khushboo, however, came after over four years of prosecution, persecution, and vilification. It is interesting to note that the outfits which waged a jihad against her could scarcely be categorized as Rightwing. The DPI claims to be fighting for the Dalits—literally, ‘the oppressed.’ These outcastes were discriminated against in Hindu scriptures. The very name of the party was inspired by that of Black Panther Party of the US. The PMK, too, claims to represent a supposedly ‘backward’ community.
The Khushboo affair underlines not only the threats to the freedom of speech and expression but also the blurring of ideological divisions in India. The parties and groups which are often called Rightist or Right-leaning also promote causes which would elsewhere be considered Leftwing. For instance, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the largest Opposition party for which the terms conservative and nationalist are used, has supported Leftwing measures like increasing the scope of affirmative action and the national rural employment guarantee scheme. All political parties prefer to conform to the dogmas of political discourse, which is clearly Leftist in tone and tenor. The BJP, like other parties, has unquestioningly accepted, even internalized, many premises and principles of the dominant political discourse.
The consequences of ideological straitjacketing have been deplorable. All parties, willy-nilly, end up supporting the causes promoted by the Left: the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005; the reserving one-third seats for women in the Lower House of Parliament and in state Assemblies; the recently notified Right to Education Act; and long goes the list of measures that the Left—though small as far as numbers are concerned—has been able to impose on the nation.
Another group promoting big state measures, and which is often aligned with Leftists or Marxists, comprises political leaders who represent various Dalit or ‘backward’ castes. The ideological straitjacketing is so tight and vicious that even a murmur of protest against any proposal by these parties or leaders is immediately dubbed as anti-poor, anti-Dalit, anti-backward, elitist, etc. Needless to say, reason and commonsense have almost been ostracized from political discourse, which is swayed by sentimentalism.
This brings us to another conspicuous feature of Indian politics: the proclivity of politicians to appeal to the crudest, crassest, and basest of public sentiments. It happens all the time. A Hindi film was named Billu barber; some caste group found the word ‘barber’ offensive. The filmmaker was forced to drop the word ‘barber’ from the name. The lyrics of a Hindi film song had to be changed; Teli ka tel (edible oil made by oil-maker) was replaced by Dilli ka tel (oil from Delhi) because the traditional oil-makers, or Telis, objected to the word. The mere mention of a word denoting a profession becomes politically incorrect.
Pandering to the lowest common denominator has put sanctimoniousness on premium and has made reason a useless virtue; it has also ensured that PC in India fashions a trajectory for itself quite different from that in the West. Spewing gross sentimentalism brings immediate publicity which, in turn, sometimes also translates into political and pecuniary gains. Unsurprisingly, most attacks on the freedom of expression are made on the pretext that the movie, book, etc, “hurt the sentiments” of this or that community.
In the US, there are writers and groups fighting PC; they regularly point out the ludicrousness and menace of PC. In India, PC is wreaking havoc with all political parties—the Leftist, the Rightist, and the Centrist—seeking to capitalize on it.

Others also do it?

If anybody claims that Islamic terror is doctrinally justified (which is a fact), they are confronted with the fallacious argument that other religions are no better. There are portions in the scriptures of Christianity and Hinduism that are not exactly in consonance with the ideas and ideals of the Enlightenment. Since all religions have preached violence—and their adherents have slaughtered non-believers, the blasphemous, and heretics—Islam should not be singled out for doing so. QED.
The fallacy lies essentially in blurring the timeline, misinterpreting the impact of various theologies, and leveling religions. It is true that the scriptures of other religions also preach violence. In the Bible, Lord sanctions the enslaving of strangers or heathens; He also exhorts the faithful to kill anyone who worships a different god .
Similarly, in a famous verse, the sacred Hindu epic, Ramacharitamanas, says, “A drum, a rustic, a Shudra (an outcaste), a beast and a woman—all these deserve to be beaten. Similarly, Manusmriti, the book by the preeminent lawgiver, Manu, makes derogatory remarks about women and Shudras. In short, it is not only Islamic scriptures which preach violence and intensify prejudice; the religious texts of other faiths are no better in this regard.
For centuries, Hindu texts have not only molded legislation and social mores in India—in the same fashion that Christian dogma and prejudice have been the cause of witch-hunts and atrocities on Jews and heretics. In India, religious bias still sometimes results into unspeakable atrocities.
But the point is that today Hindus and Christians are not doing the terrible things that their forebears did in the medieval period. Nor are they demanding that the polity and society should be reorganized according to their religious texts. In the case of Islam, however, such demands are forcefully made—and accepted partially or fully. A large number of Muslims, including many educated and apparently Westernized Muslims, want Shariat to be the fount of jurisprudence.
Worse, liberals compare the atrocities perpetrated by the Hindus and Christians in the medieval period with jihadi terror in the 21st century, and try to show that there is nothing exceptional about such terror.
The fact is that Islamic terror in this day and age is exceptional: while the adherents of other faiths have discarded the distasteful elements of their religions, Muslims refuse to follow suit. A vast majority of them believes that the Koran is the Word of Allah and, therefore, is unalterable. Exegesis has found little space in Islamic theology—at least, till date. Other religions like Hinduism and Christianity have evolved over the centuries. The way Hinduism was practiced in the 14th century—myriad rituals, degradation of Shudras, subjugation of women, elaborate caste rules, rigid customs—is not how it is done today. Ditto with Christianity. It is not that nothing has changed in the Muslim world but the change has come in spite of, not because of, Islam.
Muslim scholars and many non-Muslim experts on Islam do not deny the lack of evolution in the Islamic world, but they refuse to see anything wrong with Islam. For instance, Mohamed Charfi—a Professor of Law in Tunis, Minister for Education (1989-94), a great reformist intellectual who was sentenced to two years' imprisonment—says, “Islam is no less capable of evolution than Christianity or Judaism. But whereas, over the past few centuries, Europeans have undergone profound technological, economic, cultural and political changes, often amid considerable suffering and with major ebbs and flows, the Muslim peoples have fallen greatly behind in all spheres. This is not a fate to which they are doomed for ever; it is possible for them to close the gap.”
The unwillingness to look beyond the “technological, economic, cultural and political” factors, the reluctance to examine Islamic theology is at the root of problem. Hinduism, Christianity, and other religions have been subjected to thorough scholarly scrutiny. The loathsome practice of female feticide is (rightly) attributed to certain Hindu beliefs. But when it comes to Islam… well, we have to be careful.
Then there is the issue of religions leveling. Well-known Islamic scholar Karen Armstrong wrote, “Every fundamentalist movement I’ve studied in Judaism, Christianity and Islam is convinced at some gut, visceral level that secular liberal society wants to wipe out religion.”
Notice the dangerous syllogism. All fundamentalist movements are illiberal; Islamic fundamentalism is also illiberal; ergo, it is no worse than other fundamentalist movements. The danger lies in confusing the magnitudes: Hindu and Christian fundamentalists might have been involved a few, sporadic violent incidents, but neither the scale and scope has been as vast as evident in the case of jihadis nor the level of organization and commitment as exhibited by al-Qaeda.
The entire Muslim and liberal enterprise is oriented around the unexamined axiom that the violence by jihadis is not about Islam. But, as Salman Rushdie said in a famous post-9/11 article, this is about Islam.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Rule by law: Delhi minister harasses hotel

Delhi’s Social Welfare & Labour Minister Mangat Ram Singhal’s vindictiveness against a five-star hotel demonstrates how government agencies are used and abused by politicians to serve their personal ends.
The security staff of the hotel committed the cardinal sin of checking Singhal’s car. Since most politicians consider themselves as above law, the honorable got so furious. So, he unleashed eight inspectors on the hotel. Even by the standards of Indian politics, the display of might was so disgraceful that Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit felt ashamed. She decided to rein in the wayward minister and his men. She reprimanded Singhal; she also pulled up senior officers of the departments involved such as Labour, Excise, Health, Finance, Prevention of Food Adulteration and Electrical. She is said to have castigated the officers for “wasting government resources” and ordered them to apologise to the hotel individually.
It was a big hotel, run by a leading company. The ill-treatment meted out to it was righted by a sensible chief minister. One wonders about the plight of smaller enterprises which are always at the mercy of our political masters and the paraphernalia that they have under them to dictate terms.
This is not the rule of law; this is the rule by law. Aristotle favored the rule of law, writing that “law should govern”; those in power should be “servants of the laws.”
One of the prerequisites of modern democracy is the rule of law. A prominent political scientist, Li Shuguang, illuminates us by distinguishing the rule of law by the rule by law. “The difference.... is that under the rule of law the law is preeminent and can serve as a check against the abuse of power. Under rule by law, the law can serve as a mere tool for a government that suppresses in a legalistic fashion.”
The Singhal episode clearly shows that we have the rule by law. It has also highlighted the fact that the government officials are putty in the hands of politicians. A few days ago, the then Indian Premier League Commissioner, Lalit Modi, was interrogated by officials. The timing made it all obvious: it came just after his well-publicized fight with former minister of state for external affairs Shashi Tharoor. The high and mighty in New Delhi were offended: how could an upstart cricket czar take on one of us. So, the empire struck back. Unfortunately, non-Congress regimes have been equally bad on this count. The Atal Bihari Vajpayee government, for instance, vengefully persecuted and prosecuted the promoters and financiers of Tehelka after the Bangaru Laxman affair.
The politicians are unlikely to promote the rule of law. We, the people of India, will have to do that.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Enemies of pleasure

The puritan, wrote Thomas B Macaulay, hated bear baiting, not because it gave pain to the bear, but because it gave pleasure to the spectators. There are not many puritans in India in the literal sense of the word—that is, a significant grouping of English-speaking Protestants in the 16th and 17th-century. But the puritanical spirit is ubiquitous in our political class. Our netas are aghast that people are having fun. Make no mistake about it: they are not scandalized because a minister has been found involved in financial irregularities—Shashi Tharoor is not the first minister to have faced such accusations and, unfortunately, would not be the last one; they are outraged that something so glitzy and glamorous has become so popular. Rockstar status of cricketers, jazzy cheerleaders, dance and drama, the entire nation glued to TV sets—how could the people be allowed to have so much pleasure? So, senior Congress leader and Overseas Indians Minister Vayalar Ravi feels that the Indian Premier League is “glorified gambling.” Communist Party of India (CPI) MP Gurudas Dasgupta made is clear that the Tharoor episode was just tangential. “The minister’s resignation is not the issue. The issue is the IPL... (The) issue is laundering of money. All this is happening under the nose of the Government of India… Cricket is being maligned in the country. Wrong message is given to the budding cricketers to join the Twenty20 and earn crores.”
Then there was also the Yadav triumvirate—Lalu Prasad (RJD), Mulayam Singh Yadav (SP) and Sharad Yadav (JD-U). They want the Government to disband the IPL which has become a “betting and gambling ring.” Sharad Yadav alleged that IPL was “vulgar” and a “den of vices, black money and loot.” Notice how vague allegations—at least at the time when such remarks were made in Parliament—have been blindly accepted as gospel truth. Also notice the sermonizing by the leaders who do not have even an iota of regard for democracy, Parliamentary decorum, and decency—as evident from their words and deeds over the Women’s Reservation Bill. Yet another point to be noticed is the broad consensus across the political and ideological spectrum; everybody is railing against a sporting event that is lapped up by the people. Do the politicians fear that the IPL phenomenon would undermine their own popularity? Well, IPL cannot hurt the prospects of politicians. So, are our political masters angry just because the people love IPL? This seems to be more likely, because there is a strong moralizing streak in our netas; they prefer carefully laid-out prescriptions and proscriptions. Quite evidently, the IPL entertainment flouts doesn’t give a damn to the preachy sermons of our political masters. Perhaps, this enrages them.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Human rights groups: Maoists’ B-team

That human rights groups often act as B-team or over-ground operatives of Maoists is becoming increasingly evident. Often, the sympathies, if not affiliations, become obvious. A few recent statements by human rights champions smack of their ideological leanings.
People’s Union for Democratic Rights, Delhi (PUDR) secretary Gautam Navlakha wrote in The Economic Times (February 26), that the war against CPI (Maoist) should “be replaced by dialogue... The war on Maoists is not because they want to overthrow the presently-constituted Indian state—they have been trying that for nearly half a century.
“And, according to senior Maoist leaders themselves, it will take another 50-60 years to succeed. Besides, at present, in the PM’s words, the Maoists possess ‘modest capabilities.’ Nor is it because of their wanton acts of violence. The record of parliamentary parties, in varying degree of culpability, is not better, if not worse.”
Notice the audacity implicit in Navlakha’s candor: he makes no bones about the ultimate goal of the Maoists, that is, destruction of Indian democracy. Notice also the subterfuge: since the Maoists’ combat capabilities are modest, India should not take them seriously. We should fight them only after 50-60 years when they are ready! It is like saying that I should ignore my enemy who has sworn to kill me just because he is weak at this point of time! Let him strengthen himself, and then I should take him on—to get slaughtered at his hands!
And, of course, there is moral equivalence: the Maoists indulge in “wanton acts of violence,” but “the record of parliamentary parties, in varying degree of culpability, is not better, if not worse.” Such attitude is the hallmark of all arguments posited by Leftists and liberals
“Civil rights activists oppose war against our own people because political aspirations ought not to be suppressed militarily,” wrote Navlakha. Well, the Maoists are not “our own people”; they are the people of Mao. Therefore, they believe in the Great Helmsman’s dictum that power flows from the barrel of the gun. Those who live by the gun should not be complaining if they face superior firepower. And, at any rate, “political aspirations” are different from totalitarian intentions.
Unfortunately, Navlakha is not the only purveyor of lies; there are a large number of people, some of them public figures, who are compulsively mendacious. On March 1, some of them called a press conference to lament that the Indian state has turned monstrous in its war on Maoists (which, these worthies believe, is actually a war against tribals). Human rights activists, journalists and fact-finding committees were being targeted, advocate Prashant Bhushan alleged.
“The government has done little for the tribals and now they are trying to snatch their land. When tribals agitate peacefully, the State security forces descend on them, harass them and burn their villages. About 700 villages have been burnt in the past two years in Chhattisgarh. People are bound to protest and take up arms. For every 100 Maoists eliminated, thousands are created through collateral damage,” Bhushan said.
Notice the chicanery: the campaign against murderous Maoists has been transmogrified into a war against tribals. Of course, no evidence is given to support the outlandish claim. And those of Bhushan’s ilk will never accept that the Maoists are ruthlessly killing tribals in Chhattisgarh.
At the press conference, Justice Rajinder Sachar (Retd) was also present. This man is the embodiment of all that is ossified in India. An inveterate sympathizer of terrorists, he earned eternal disgrace for himself by heading a committee on Muslims and recommending boundless appeasement. He said: “The state cannot be a terrorist. It is the ultimate repository of law and order. Talks should happen between the government and the Maoists in an open atmosphere where there is no fear. Both sides should cease hostilities for dialogue to take place.”
The Navalakhas, the Bhushans, and the Sachars always tell us to embrace those who kill us. Pakistanis send jihadis to bomb our cities and slaughter our citizens, but we should continue to hold talks with Islamabad. The Maoists gun down our security personnel and liquidate the common citizens not falling in line—as the brave tribals in Chhattisgarh—but “talks should happen between the government and the Maoists.”
And, by the way, Mr. Sachar, which “both sides” are you talking about? Can the thuggish Maoists by any stretch of imagination be equated with the security personnel? On the one side are the followers of the world’s greatest butcher, Mao; on the other side are the soldiers of the biggest democracy. What is the comparison? Such moral equivalence just shows Sachar’s own moral bankruptcy and intellectual hollowness.
It is time the media and other opinion-makers exposed the duplicity and insidiousness of the so-called human rights activists.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

The only good Taliban is dead Taliban

Who chopped off the heads of Sikhs in the North-West province of Pakistan because they refused to convert to Islam? Is it the ‘good Taliban’—with whom US President Barack Obama, UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown and other world leaders want to do business?
I wonder how Obama, always soft on jihadis, would even describe the outrage. Under him, the Pentagon’s Quadrennial Defense Review and the Quadrennial Homeland Security Review have practically banned the use of words ‘Muslim’ or ‘Islam.’ Obamaspeak is likely to call the murderers as ‘violent extremist,’ and not jihadis, lest it hurts the sentiments of the people who follow ‘the religion of peace.’
The Taliban unleash a reign of terror, murder at will, terrorize religious minorities, subjugate women, suppress any dissenting voice, and want to herd the entire world to medieval barbarity. And what does the international community, led by the US—supposedly the champion of liberty, pluralism and democracy—do? Well, it timidly accepts Taliban ruthlessness. It even intends to buy peace, offering hundreds of millions of dollars to them, as it did at the recently held London conference to ensure their comeback.
And what does India do? Typically, it issues strong statements. “We condemn this barbaric act of Taliban who have taken into custody three of the Indian nationals. The message that I have received which needs to be updated is that one has been done away with and other two are kept under captivation,” External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna said.
Minister of State for External Affairs Parneet Kaur offered running commentary: “Last time, Sikhs were threatened to pay Jazia and Pakistan had said it is its internal matter, I appeal to Pakistan to take strict action.” Appeal to Pakistan? Did we get it right? New Delhi would appeal to those who unleashed the Taliban on the world in the first place? Could the tragedy become more farcical?
The politicians of India should get real. They should comprehend the vileness of Taliban. They should also beware of the duplicity of Islamabad.
Our leaders have failed miserably in convincing the world capitals that Pakistan’s support to the West’s war on terror is phony. Even now it is not late. India should highlight the fact that the evil Pakistan has spawned is a menace to all, and that the only good Taliban are dead Taliban.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Shameless politicians sympathize with murderers

With India facing grievous terror threat from the Maoists (or Naxalites) and jihadis, one would have expected the powers to be getting their act together to fight the mortal enemies of the nation. But, alas, that was not to be! Our political masters are not serious about the war on terror.
Consider the case of Railway Minister and Trinamool Congress Mamata Banerjee. Her ties with Maoists are no secret; in fact, she benefited because of her relations with the Naxalites in the last general elections. Her relations with the ultras adversely affected last year’s operations against them at Lalgarh.
Now, she has reportedly forced the Union Cabinet to drop from the Presidential address to the joint session of Parliament a condemnation of the murderous Naxal strike on the EFR camp at Silda in the West Midnapore district in West Bengal on February 15. Monday, which left 24 jawans dead and many injured. At the insistence of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, the Cabinet nevertheless agreed to include a general condemnation of Maoist attacks all over the country in recent months.
“What is the proof that the attack was carried out by Maoists? If at all, it appears to be the handiwork of CPM. I would urge the Prime Minister to first order an inquiry into the incident,” Mamata reportedly told her Cabinet colleagues.
In our times, the merchants of falsehood find refuge in the what-is-the-proof line of argumentation. This comes handy when one is promoting any vile cause, be it Naxalism or jihad. What is the proof that the young Muslim men killed at Batla House in Delhi in September 2008 were terrorists, cry jihadis, their sympathizers, pro-jihadi human rights groups, and pink punks. It was a fake encounter and there should be an inquiry into it, they thunder.
It is pointed out that the Batla House shootout could not have been fake because Delhi Police lost an ace officer, Inspector M.C. Sharma in it. What kind of fake encounter was it in which a cop loses his life? But the peddlers of lies persist with their demand for in inquiry.
The National Human Rights Commission probed into the matter, and reports to the Delhi High Court that the shootout was genuine. But the human rights mafia still was not satisfied. The Supreme Court looked into the matter, and it also gave a clean chit to Delhi Police.
The screaming by human rights mafia could have been ignored had it not been supported by, among others, many politicians, the most important of them being Congress general secretary Digvijay Singh. He was sympathetic to the cause upheld by the human rights mafia. He even visited Azamgarh, the UP district which has shot into notoriety because of being the hub of so many Islamic terrorists.
It is not that only the ruling coalition is lackadaisical in its attitude towards Maoists and jihadis, the Bharatiya Janata Party is little better. The saffron leaders spew fiery rhetoric when talking about terrorists, but they are willing to match practice with precept. In Jharkhand, they are in power, but have no problems with Chief Minister Shibu Soren’s soft approach towards Naxalites.
The Maoists and jihadis murder our citizens, shoot down our security personnel, bomb our cities, and want to establish a reign of terror. And our netas sympathize with them! The question to be asked in India is not whether we would win the war against terror, but whether our politicians are even willing to fight that war all earnestness.

Saturday, February 13, 2010

Jairam Ramesh bows to green terror

The merchants of mendacity have scored a big victory by forcing Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh to place an indefinite “moratorium” on the introduction of a genetically-modified brinjal. His colleague in the Council of Ministers, Kapil Sibal, was candid enough to say that Ramesh “bowed to populism.”
This was yet another case of green terrorists abusing science to promote their Luddite and socialist agendas. Years after Centre for Science and Environment chief Sunita Narain carried out her deceitful tirade against cola companies, and weeks after IPCC boss R.K. Pachauri was exposed for running his shop by peddling voodoo science, we have a situation in which India science has faced a setback. The country’s top apex technical committee, the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) has been ignored because a bunch of econuts clamored against an innovation in the farm sector.
To be fair to Ramesh, he did not have much of a choice. Protest against Bt brinjal was quite widespread. The RSS—never comfortable with science and modernity and too willing to accept Left shibboleths—spoke against Bt brinjal. The ban on the innovation in the BJP-ruled Uttarakhand, Karnataka and Himachal Pradesh was a logical culmination. At the same time, green loonies who run myriad non-governmental organizations (NGOs) already were screaming.
Ramesh claimed that “sentiment was negative” at the public hearings in seven cities. Sentiment? Is science run by sentiments? And, by the way, whose sentiments?
Dr. M Mahadevappa, a two-time former vice-chancellor of the University of Agriculture Sciences, Dharwad, who attended the public hearing in Bangalore, was quoted in The Indian Express, “I was out-shouted by the NGO lobbies the moment I began speaking. I could not express my views. Public hearings of the sort that were arranged are not the right place where scientific issues can be discussed in an objective manner.”
The UAS, Dharwad, and the Tamil Nadu Agriculture University, Coimbatore, actively collaborated in developing Bt Brinjal.
“I have been working with several Krishi Vigyan Kendras in Karnataka for several years and I have found no opposition from farmers against Bt brinjal. Even at the Bangalore meeting, I was opposed by the NGOs and not by the farmers,” Dr. Mahadevappa said.
Dr. B.C. Viraktamath, project director at the Directorate of Rice Research in Hyderabad, was not even allowed to enter the building where the hearing was going on. “The way the consultations were held, it was very clear that the entire exercise was random with a disproportionate representation of protestors,” he said.
Another scientist, Dr. M. Sujatha, of the Directorate of Oilseeds Research at Hyderabad, said, “This is not the right kind of approach to solicit views on such a complex issue. The minister could have held separate meetings with scientists, farmers and NGOs to get a more balanced and clear picture.”
Chengal Reddy, a farmers’ leader, questioned the representativeness of protestors. “Who is this ‘general public’? The general public had even opposed computers when they were first launched.”
Actually, it is the mafia of NGOs, sundry pink punks, and green terrorists who make so much noise that they are often assumed to be the representatives of people. The truth, however, is that these busybodies are just promoting their vile, retrograde agenda in the name of championing the cause of public.